Why HD DVD vs Blu-ray is still a cold war

The battle to convince people that HD formats are the way to go, is only just beginning

The high definition format war is failing to heat up in North America, with most punters choosing regular DVD titles over HD DVD and Blu-ray ones.

Paramount announced today that it sold 190,000 HD DVD copies of the new Transformers movie in its first week of release. That compares to the 8.3 million copies which were sold in the same period on standard definition DVD.

HD discs: doomed formats?

But despite the numbers arguing otherwise, HD DVD-exclusive studio Paramount is hailing the figures as evidence that HD DVD is doing better than the rival Blu-ray format.

"[Transformers] rocketed past previous releases to become the fastest and best-selling day one high definition title on a single format," says Paramount. "[The HD DVD version] has sold over 190,000 HD DVDs in its first week making it the top-selling week one release on either high definition format as well as the best-selling HD DVD ever."

It's amazing how both the Blu-ray and the HD DVD camps are parading their woefully small sales figures as though they are actually significant. The DVD version of Transformers sold 44 times as many as the HD DVD version, which demonstrates what a battle the HD formats have in order to win over the general consumer.

HD's biggest competitor? It's DVD

Most HD movies are outsold even more severely by their DVD counterparts.

And while the figures in North America are looking bad, the battle to win over the hearts and minds of those of us in the UK and Europe is even worse.

We called the HD DVD Promotion Group Europe's PR department this morning to find out the HD DVD sales figures for Europe. They said they had none at present. Make of that what you will.

James Rivington

James was part of the TechRadar editorial team for eight years up until 2015 and now works in a senior position for TR's parent company Future. An experienced Content Director with a demonstrated history of working in the media production industry. Skilled in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), E-commerce Optimization, Journalism, Digital Marketing, and Social Media. James can do it all.

Latest in Blu-ray
The movie Punch-Drunk Love playing a TV, with a logo saying Blu-ray Bounty
3 new 4K Blu-rays to add to your collection from February 2025
4K Blu-ray action movies splayed out on a kitchen counter
Movie sales – including 4K Blu-ray – fell again last year, but if you're going streaming only, you're massively missing out
The Wild Robot on Panasonic MZ1500 screen with Blu-ray Bounty logo in bottom right
3 new 4K Blu-rays to add to your collection in January 2025
4K Blu-ray action movies splayed out on a kitchen counter
I love 4K Blu-ray and although 2024 was a rollercoaster year to be a fan, I'm hopeful for 2025
Godzilla (1954) image of buildings on OLED TV
4 new 4K Blu-ray discs to add to your collection in December 2024
blu-ray disc in player drive
Bad news, Blu-ray fans: LG just discontinued its entire range of 4K Blu-ray players and I’m really worried
Latest in News
Helly and Mark standing on an artificial hill surrounded by goats in Severance season 2 episode 3
New Apple teaser for Severance season 2 finale suggests we might finally find out what Lumon is doing with those goats, and I don't think it's anything good
Foldable iPhone
Apple’s first foldable iPhone could beat the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7 in one key way
Marvel Rivals
Marvel Rivals' next update will add two new hero skins for Iron Man and Spider-Man mains this week
Nvidia Isaac GROOT N1
“The age of generalist robotics is here" - Nvidia's latest GROOT AI model just took us another step closer to fully humanoid robots
Lego Pokemon
Pokemon and Lego announce the most electrifying collaboration of all time and I’m going to be first in line
Apple Watch app health
Apple Watch blood pressure monitoring tech revealed in patent