Apple AirTags might have a major flaw

Apple AirTags
Apple AirTags (Image credit: Apple)

If you're considering buying the new Apple AirTags location trackers, you might first want to consider where you live - reports suggest the tags aren't working too well in buildings with loads of floors.

This was first raised by XDA Developers, in that site's review of the AirTags, which noted issues with the elevation aspect of the product - but this flaw could be wider-reaching than the review notes.

The review states "If I’ve misplaced my keys with an AirTag key ring on one floor (say, the gym) and I’m on another floor, my iPhone will not be able to use Precision Finding (because the phone is too far away). If I use general tracking, it’ll tell me the AirTag is in my current building - and that’s it."

So the AirTags won't accurately recognize which floor of a building you're on - likely because they're designed to be used on Apple's 2D or 2.5D maps. The review goes on to say "I concede my living situation is unique" as if to suggest the altitude problem isn't a huge deal for wider audiences. But depending on what you do for a living, or your normal habits, it really could be.

Diversity of life

While the XDA Developers report suggests the AirTags don't work well in a multi-story high-rise apartment, based on this problem, there are loads of other situations in which issues could arise.

For example, if you work in an office with multiple floors and rooms, are staying at a large hotel, or are attending (or working at) a hospital, school, government building or similar, you'll also have issues locating your AirTags with your iPhone.

Since these are all places you could get anxious about losing your possessions - losing your bag in a hotel, or misplacing something in your work's office, can be a frequent occurrence for some - they're arguably the times AirTags really need to work right.

The locational issues with Apple's AirTags aren't their only flaws - they're expensive, don't work with Android phones.

But hopefully, if this geographic problem gets fixed, the AirTags will be useful for a few more people.

TOPICS
Tom Bedford
Contributor

Tom Bedford joined TechRadar in early 2019 as a staff writer, and left the team as deputy phones editor in late 2022 to work for entertainment site (and TR sister-site) What To Watch. He continues to contribute on a freelance basis for several sections including phones, audio and fitness.

Read more
GlocalMe KeyTracker
When I tested this global tracker, it trounced the Apple AirTag in so many ways
Apple AirTags
AirTag 2 upgrade could bring significant improvements to Apple’s trackers
AirTag deals hero image
Sick of losing your keys? This Apple AirTags 4-pack is at a record-low price
Find My app logo displayed on an iPhone 11 screen
This Find My exploit lets hackers track any Bluetooth device – here’s how you can stay safe
The Elevation Labs TimeCapsule case for the Apple AirTag.
Sick of your AirTags dying on you? This new accessory gives them a decade-long battery life
Apple Airtag four pack on orange background with lowest price sign
The Apple AirTags are now even cheaper than Black Friday thanks to a surprise price cut at Amazon
Latest in Computing
Deep Resarch
I test AI agents for a living and these are the 5 reasons you should let tools like ChatGPT Deep Research get things done for you
ChatGPT vs. Manus
I compared Manus AI to ChatGPT – now I understand why everyone is calling it the next DeepSeek
Vision Pro Metallica
Apple Vision Pro goes off to never never land with Metallica concert footage
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 on a table with its retail packaging
Nvidia RTX 5060 GPU spotted in Acer gaming PC, suggesting rumors of imminent launch are correct – and that it’ll run with only 8GB of video RAM
cyberpowerpc gamer supreme gaming PC on orange background with don't miss text overlay
I've looked through all the available RX 9070 XT pre-builts and this is the gaming PC I'd buy with my own cash
Image of Asus VU34WCIP monitor
Asus might have just changed the display game for good with three new air-purifying monitors - and one of them is ultrawide
Latest in News
Google Chromecast 2
Chromecasts are still broken – but Google tells fuming owners not to factory reset their devices
Garmin Instinct 3 next to the Apple Watch Ultra 2
New figures claim the smartwatch market just shrunk for the first time ever, and the Apple Watch Ultra 3 is to blame
Hitman: World of Assassination on PSVR 2.
Hitman: World of Assassination hits PSVR 2 soon, finally giving you a reason to dust off your headset
Hector Ayala sitting on a bed as he wears his White Tiger costume in Daredevil: Born Again season 1
Daredevil: Born Again episode 3's shocking final scene is a big misdirect, and I've got the evidence to back it up
A stressed employee looking over some graphs
UK workers are spending more than one day per week tracking down information
Vision Pro Metallica
Apple Vision Pro goes off to never never land with Metallica concert footage