Instagram is tagging real photos as 'Made with AI' – and photographers aren't happy

An Instagram post by bothingbutpixies of Jennifer Aniston that has a Made with AI tag
(Image credit: nothingbutpixies)

Some Instagram users have recently noticed a 'Made with AI' tag appearing in the top left of reels and posts. In many cases, the tag is appearing on real photos and not images made using an AI image generator as the tag implies, and photographers aren't happy about it.

So what is going on? Instagram users @colinandsamir posed the question to the Head of Instagram Adam Mosseri (@mosseri) to clear things up (see below) and he said: 

"It's just the metadata on the image. People are doing benign things in Photoshop that are technically using AI. And then we're just respecting the file's mark saying 'Hey, AI was used to make this.' We have to figure this out because clearly this is frustrating and not the ideal experience."

Disgruntled photographers have not taken kindly to the suggestion that their images are fake, but are instead real photos that are edited using Adobe Photoshop which has improved AI editing tricks.

For some creators such as Peter McKinnon, Instagram's binary tagging approach feels like an overreach.

Matters get complicated and fast: Instagram is also adding the 'Made with AI' tag on many AI-generated images and ultimately expecting viewers to use their own judgement as to what's real, so we're back at square one. 

In a time when AI will make it almost impossible to know the truth, Instagram's degree of caution is understandable but that's of little comfort to photographers sharing real albeit edited images that are being tarred with the same AI-generated brush. 

And, as Mosseri goes on to say, there continues to be content online that is generated by AI that is not tagged to that effect and could therefore be assumed as being real, "There will be content on all platforms that is made with AI and is not marked with AI because the person who made it specifically tried to avoid that."

Handling AI content online remains a complex task.

What else can Instagram do?

Instagram scans the metadata of an image to ascertain if it's real or AI-generated. Those savvy enough to upload an image without metadata – for example, a screenshot – can circumvent Instagram's tag with their fake images.

Meanwhile, a photographer who used Photoshop's content-aware tools to remove a blemish on skin of a real person or a stain on clothing could be lumped with the 'Made with AI' tag if those changes are in the image metadata. Clearly, the situation is far from ideal, but it's also far from straightforward to navigate. 

Instagram users have been responding to Colin and Samir's Instagram posts with mixed feelings and their own ideas of how Instagram should point out fake images. 

User @voust says, "There should be 'edited with AI and made with AI'... 'made' kind of implies the whole image is artificial". 

@voust suggests an alternative to Instagram's binary approach for photographers for whom authenticity matters: it could scan real photos with Adobe's Content Credentials metadata that proves authenticity, along with if there were any edits made to the image to avoid the 'Made with AI' tag, and that an 'edited with AI' tag is acceptable.

Photographers have been faking and manipulating photographs ever since the invention of photography, but we're on new AI ground that adds a whole other layer. Photoshop's Generative Fill AI tools are pushing what's possible in its flagship editor, and confusing what's real.

In photography circles, AI-generated images aren't seen as photographs, nor is replacing an entire sky in your photo using Photoshop's Generative Fill, while light editing of real photos is on the whole acceptable – and it's verging on insulting that these edited photos are being tagged as 'Made with AI'. 

A single 'Made with AI' tag leaves too many questions and in some cases unfair suspicion. To a degree, 'edited with AI' also leaves questions: how much editing has taken place; an entirely new landscape around your subject or simply a small piece of litter removed from the ground?  

I think Instagram is on the right track, but I also hope that it listens to photographers and finds a more acceptable way forward.

You might also like

Timothy Coleman
Cameras editor

Tim is the Cameras editor at TechRadar. He has enjoyed more than 15 years in the photo video industry with most of those in the world of tech journalism. During his time as Deputy Technical Editor with Amateur Photographer, as a freelancer and consequently editor at Tech Radar, Tim has developed a deeply technical knowledge and practical experience with cameras, educating others through news, reviews and features. He’s also worked in video production for Studio 44 with clients including Canon, and volunteers his spare time to consult a non-profit, diverse stories team based in Nairobi. Tim is curious, a keen creative, avid footballer and runner, and moderate flat white drinker who has lived in Kenya and believes we have much to enjoy and learn from each other. 

Read more
Photographer taking photo at sunset.
AI is changing camera tech for the better but photography for the worse
Adobe Photoshop AI tools in action
What is Adobe Photoshop: Everything we know about the image editor’s AI tools
Cutout Pro
What is Cutout.pro? Everything we know about AI video tool
CyberLink PhotoDirector AI examples on the homepage
AI Photo Editing: Top 7 tools to boost your productivity
Multiple products with AI
Why is AI in everything these days? What you need to know about the world’s favorite buzzword
A hand holding a phone showing a photo of a musician being edited in the Photoshop for iPhone app
I'm a Photoshop pro – here are 5 things I love about the new iPhone app and 3 things I don’t
Latest in Photography
Xiaomi 15 Ultra smartphone housed in the Xiaomi Photography Kit, with user hold the phone up to take a photo outdoors
I swapped my $3,000 camera for the Xiaomi 15 Ultra for a month – here's what I learned
Nikon Z6 III camera in the hand with no lens attached and full-frame sensor on display
What's the best camera sensor format? You told us your clear favorite – here's why it's not that simple
Lunar eclipse
I'm a pro photographer – here's how I'm shooting the total lunar eclipse blood moon with my camera and phone
A young man takes a portrait photo with a DSLR.
Sell Smart: Quick, easy, and secure camera gear solutions with MPB
Shooting with a Samsung Galaxy Ultra smartphone
I shot and edited this photo with my Samsung Galaxy Ultra and Adobe Lightroom Mobile – here's how you can get pro results with just your phone
A hand holding the Ricoh GR IIIx camera
My photography resolution for 2025 is to keep a point-and-shoot compact in my pocket, and to actually use it!
Latest in Features
The Claude, ChatGPT, Google Gemini and Perplexity logos, clockwise from top left
The ultimate AI search face-off - I pitted Claude's new search tool against ChatGPT Search, Perplexity, and Gemini, the results might surprise you
The home screen on an iPhone 16e smartphone
I think the iPhone 16e is too expensive – and as it turns out, so does nearly everybody else
Helly R and Mark S look shocked in Severance season 2
5 questions Severance season 3 needs to answer when the Apple TV+ hit returns
Neon artwork of a stylised SSD against a brick wall.
The dawn of PCIe 7.0 could mean faster SSDs for everyone - but not just yet
Resident Evil 4 Remake Ashley
Forget the Steam Spring Sale that's just ended, these are the six best deals that are still available and I've got in my basket right now
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 in Paris in front of the Louvre pyramid
5 things I want from the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7