Did Google just steal Apple’s AI thunder, or has Tim Cook got an ace in his back pocket?

Three iPhones on a blue and red background running Apple Intelligence
(Image credit: Apple)

I’m sitting here basking in the afterglow of all the new products Google just showed at its Made for Google event, where it launched a raft of new Google Pixel 9 phones, Google Pixel Watch 3 and Google Pixel Buds 2 Pro. While the new phones would normally be the stars of the show, this time they played second fiddle to the software that ran on them, specifically Gemini Live, it’s all encompassing AI digital assistant that’s baked right into the heart of Android 15. 

Google demonstrated the best AI feature I’ve seen so far - the ability to talk to your phone and have it answer back, as if it were a human being. This is a next-level digital assistant and Gemini Live stole the show, despite a cringe-worthy moment when the live demo failed spectacularly, twice. Live demos at Google product launches have a long history of going badly, so I’m surprised that Google still continues to do them.

Here’s a demo of Gemini Live, which works this time:

@techradar

♬ original sound - TechRadar

Gemini Live lets you do more than just talk, too. Take a picture of a poster for an event and then ask Gemini if you’re free on that date to go and see the show, or take a picture of your fridge and ask it what you could cook with those ingredients, and it will come up with some helpful suggestions.

Of course, nothing in the AI world ever seems to be quite finished. Gemini’s most useful integration features are its ability to look in your Calendar and Gmail apps to answer really helpful digital assistant-style questions, like, “Can you remind me what Tim said about the bowling game next week?”. But these features have a ‘coming soon’ label applied to them. I’m sure they will arrive soon, but AI is slowly gaining a reputation for rocky rollouts. For instance, Bloomberg has already cast doubts on Apple’s ability to have Apple Intelligence fully functioning in time for the launch of the iPhone 16 this September.

AI is still struggling to find a valid reason to exist on our devices, but thanks to Google Gemini, the main benefit of AI is getting clearer and clearer. It’s all about fundamentally changing the way you interact with your phone. In comparison, the AI image manipulation features that both Apple and Google have showed off so far are impressive, but they feel a bit like gimmicks that you’ll try once or twice then forget about; good for product demos, but not much else. 

When it comes down to who has the better AI, Apple or Google, we’ll only know that once the iPhone 16 launches and we get to quiz Siri beyond its beta versions. We know that Google has now set the bar very high for natural conversation with an AI, thanks to Gemini Live, but the killer feature that Apple could beat it on is the price. Apple Intelligence will be free to everyone lucky enough to own an iPhone 15 Pro or better, or a Mac with an M-series processor. Gemini Live is for Gemini Advanced subscribers only, and that’s $20 a month. So for once, Apple seems to be about to beat Google at its own game, by releasing a free service.

You may also like

Graham Barlow
Senior Editor, AI

Graham is the Senior Editor for AI at TechRadar. With over 25 years of experience in both online and print journalism, Graham has worked for various market-leading tech brands including Computeractive, PC Pro, iMore, MacFormat, Mac|Life, Maximum PC, and more. He specializes in reporting on everything to do with AI and has appeared on BBC TV shows like BBC One Breakfast and on Radio 4 commenting on the latest trends in tech. Graham has an honors degree in Computer Science and spends his spare time podcasting and blogging.

Read more
Pixel 9 Pro og Pixel 9 Pro XL
Gemini AI can see and talk to you about what's on your screen – which could be more helpful than it sounds
Google Gemini AI
Gemini can now see your screen and judge your tabs
a google TV
I got a sneak peek of 3 great new AI features for Google Home devices and TVs, and one is straight out of a Black Mirror episode
Gemini 2.0
What is Gemini: everything you need to know about Google’s AI chatbot
Google Gemini AI
Google Gemini is racing to win the AI crown in 2025
Gemini 2.0
Google has just announced the ability to chain actions in Gemini and it could change the way we use AI for good
Latest in Artificial Intelligence
AI hallucinations
We're already trusting AI with too much – I just hope AI hallucinations disappear before it's too late
Google Gemini AI
Gemini can now see your screen and judge your tabs
A phone showing a ChatGPT app error message
ChatGPT was down for many – here's what happened
ChatGPT app on an iPhone
5 things you should ask ChatGPT today – oh, and 1 you should never ask it!
Hume AI
What is Hume: Bring emotional understanding to AI-generated voices
Beautiful.ai
What is Beautiful.ai: Create modern presentations in as little time as possible
Latest in Opinion
AI hallucinations
We're already trusting AI with too much – I just hope AI hallucinations disappear before it's too late
Closing the cybersecurity skills gap
How CISOs can meet the demands of new privacy regulations
Half man, half AI.
Ensuring your organization uses AI responsibly: a how-to guide
Judge sitting behind laptop in office
A day in the life of an AI-augmented lawyer
Cyber-security
Why Windows End of Life deadlines require a change of mindset
Polar Pacer
Polar's latest software update might have finally convinced me to ditch my Garmin