I miss the old Instagram - but the last thing I need is a clone from TikTok

Instagram's profile on Instagram
(Image credit: AngieYeoh / Shutterstock)

I remember when Instagram first launched back in 2010, and all my mates at school were crowded around my friend's iPhone 4 making our Instagram accounts and brainstorming cool handle ideas. Things have changed so much since then, and I truly miss the 'old' Instagram. That being said, I don’t think I miss it enough to have TikTok step in and try to fill in the gap.

A notification on the app stated that TikTok is gearing up to release a photo-sharing app for users to post their pictures, called TikTok Notes, which will also convert “existing and future public TikTok photo posts” into posts on the new platform. Currently, Tiktok users can post photo slideshows against music tracks, so it’s safe to assume these will be translated to Instagram-esque posts on the new platform. 

According to The Verge, TikTok states that it’s “exploring ways to empower our community to create and share their creativity with photos and text in a dedicated space for those formats”. So, from that, we can assume you’ll also be able to add captions to your Notes posts as well. 

Could TikTok actually take Instagram on? 

People have been done with Instagram for a while now. The idea of posting to the general public has been left largely to the influencer types, with most people I know having their Instagram account set to private and reserved for friends and family or using their 'Finstas' exclusively.  Finstas, or fake Instagrams, became super popular among young people in 2016 and onwards - a tool for those who wanted to keep using Instagram but have a section carved out to be themselves and post without worrying about having perfect photos.

Finstas still did not save Instagram from being labeled a wasteland of a platform. Where Instagram is a lot more controlled in terms of its feed, TikTok has an interesting setup in that publicly posted videos could be thrown across to anyone on the app, no matter if you’re mutually following people or not. So, it would be interesting to see how this translates to a photo-based app. 

TikTok is an insanely popular app and the fact that the new app will be incorporating already existing photo posts could give it the head start it needs to compete with Instagram. I’m assuming it’ll be a similar case to Instagram Threads, where everyone is already allocated an account and you simply have to activate it. That opens the door to TikTok's estimated one billion monthly active users to log in and try the app out.

Of course, not every social media doppelganger is guaranteed success. The downfall of Twitter (sorry, 'X') brought on several other similar apps like Mastodon and Bluesky, and despite how awful things have been on Twitter they’re not really seeing massive numbers that would make them as big as the app they’re replacing. Threads seemed to be a guaranteed hit given the number of already-established Instagram accounts, but it only has 160 monthly million users, compared to X’s 250 million daily active users. I honestly think X would have to be wiped off the web and our phones before people flocked to any of the alternatives. 

Overall though, TikTok Notes has the social media scene buzzing with anticipation. TikTok's smart move to integrate existing photo content and its massive user base could challenge Instagram's reign. Though, history teaches us that not every alternative is a winner. As TikTok Notes prepares to debut, we can only speculate about its potential to topple Instagram - or forge its own path in the digital realm.

Muskaan Saxena
Computing Staff Writer

Muskaan is TechRadar’s UK-based Computing writer. She has always been a passionate writer and has had her creative work published in several literary journals and magazines. Her debut into the writing world was a poem published in The Times of Zambia, on the subject of sunflowers and the insignificance of human existence in comparison. Growing up in Zambia, Muskaan was fascinated with technology, especially computers, and she's joined TechRadar to write about the latest GPUs, laptops and recently anything AI related. If you've got questions, moral concerns or just an interest in anything ChatGPT or general AI, you're in the right place. Muskaan also somehow managed to install a game on her work MacBook's Touch Bar, without the IT department finding out (yet).

Read more
TikTok ban
TikTok's imminent ban is pushing people to RedNote, another Chinese app, and the irony is just too rich
CapCut logo on a black and red background
CapCut hit by US ban – and in completely unrelated news, Instagram has just revealed a new video-editing app
Instagram app logo on iOS
Instagram finally has all the tools to make your own year in review for Stories
A phone showing the TikTok logo
TikTok is back on the App Store and Google Play Store – here’s what could happen next
A phone showing the TikTok logo
TikTok could immediately shut its app to millions in the US in days – here's how to prepare
TikTok logo seen on mobile with TikTok CEO Shou Zi Chew sketch displayed on screen. On 23 March 2023 in Brussels, Belgium.
TikTok will have its day in court, but it's time to ask what we'll do without it
Latest in Social Media
tiktok
How to edit TikTok videos
 Facebook social media app logo on log-in, sign-up registration page
How to delete all your Facebook posts
The logo of the social media app Bluesky is seen on the screen of a mobile phone
Bluesky gets a massive video upgrade to tempt X fans who are frustrated by its cyberattack outages
TikTok
How to download TikTok videos without a watermark
Instagram app logo on iOS
Instagram wants you to do more with DMs than just slide into someone else’s
The logo of the social media app Bluesky is seen on the screen of a mobile phone
What is Bluesky? The new social media network explained
Latest in Opinion
Apple CEO Tim Cook delivers remarks before the start of an Apple event at Apple headquarters on September 09, 2024 in Cupertino, California. Apple held an event to showcase the new iPhone 16, Airpods and Apple Watch models. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
The big Siri Apple Intelligence delay proves that maybe we really don't know Apple at all
Racks of servers inside a data center.
Modernizing data centers: an efficient path forward
Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max REVIEW
Apple Intelligence is a fever dream that I bet Apple wishes we could all forget about
Asus ROG Ally using Steam
I think Asus could be the perfect partner for an Xbox handheld – but I have questions
Hands typing on a keyboard surrounded by security icons
The psychology of scams: how cybercriminals are exploiting the human brain
A person using a desktop computer.
The role of automation in achieving sustainability goals