Meta Orion could be our AR future, but not with the lenses you'll get

Meta Orion
(Image credit: Future / Lance Ulanoff)

You will never own a pair of Meta Orion AR glasses – at least not like what I saw yesterday at Meta Connect 2024. That's what I told myself after reading early hands-on reports that made one thing very clear about the ground-breaking smart glasses introduced this week by wunderkind turned billionaire CEO, and now cool guy Mark Zuckerberg.

It's not that Orion can't do the things Zuckerberg claimed during his buzz-worthy keynote. Orion is a pair of somewhat thick, black-framed glasses featuring what looks like see-through screens (more on that in a bit), hand and eye tracking, neural input (via a wrist device), and the ability to integrate virtual environments with your real one almost seamlessly.

The demo was exciting and reminded me a bit of what Magic Leap showed off almost a decade ago. It too had apparently excellent resolution, a wide field of view, and appeared to serve as a bridge between real and virtual worlds. Unfortunately, the reality of the hardware never lived up to the hype. The images were desaturated, and the field of view narrow. It required physical connectivity to a pack, and looked more like goggles than glasses. The company is still around but now focuses on enterprise customers (a final destination for almost all mixed-reality headsets).

Meta Orion

(Image credit: Future / Lance Ulanoff)

Meta Orion is not Magic Leap. First of all, in addition to showing the new AR glasses on stage (roughly 50 feet away from where I sat), Meta gave hands-on demos to a handful of celebrities, industry figures (including Gary Vee and Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang), and some media outlets.

What's clear from all of them is that this is real. The AR glasses function more or less as Zuckerberg promised. They offer full-frame 'displays' that use waveform microLED projector technology to light up the transparent silicon carbide lens with an image. That's exciting because it means the viewport for these AR glasses could exceed most AR glasses on the market. No more glancing up at a special area where the AR experience will live. If you wear glasses every day as I do, eyesight correction must span your entire field of view. AR won't be immersive unless it similarly can appear wherever I cast my eyes. Orion could be like wearing regular glasses, but with a hidden superpower.

That glee you saw on the faces of those who experienced Orion firsthand might never be your glee.

The "neural interface" is a bit of a push. It's just a wristband that can, I think, read subtle hand gestures through the muscles and tendons in the wrist. That's not neural technology as I understand it. Still, I like the idea of combining that control with eye tracking. That could be pretty intuitive. Of course, the $3,499 Apple Vision Pro reads hand gestures without a wristband.

Orion AR glasses still look like glasses not so much because of a big breakthrough; there's a pocket puck where much of the processing power lives. At least it's wireless.

Even with these caveats, this is an exciting bit of technology and I can't wait for it to hit the market. Except it never will.

Meta Orion

(Image credit: Future / Lance Ulanoff)

According to the Verge's hands-on report, this version of Meta Orion will never see the light of day. The company is already working on thinner and lighter versions. And while that sounds good, there is one very significant caveat. The silicon carbide lenses (material that is typically used in aerospace and the semiconductor industries) can't be manufactured affordably at scale, and that means Orion V2 will not have them. As a result, the shipping Orions, if and when they arrive, will have a smaller field of view.

Meta told the Verge that the screen will be sharper and brighter, but that doesn't really matter to me. The key to a transformative AR experience is not just its ability to connect the physical world to your virtual one, it's about how borders don't break that illusion. A smaller field of view will mean that the AR magic breaks quickly and will only be available to a portion of your viewport. That adjustment will change the Orion experience from transformative to unsatisfying, if not gimmicky.

Meta Orion

(Image credit: Future / Lance Ulanoff)

That glee you saw on the faces of those who experienced Orion firsthand might never be your glee. Some of the shipping Orion experience might make you smile, but then you'll glance to the left or right or look too far up or down and your AR will vanish.

Maybe I'm wrong, but think about how Zuckerberg announced these frames. He specifically pointed out the silicon carbide lenses as a defining feature, something chosen for its excellent refractive capabilities, critical when you're projecting an image onto a surface that has to then reach your eyes. Essentially making the entire lens a screen was an act of brilliance and now, it appears, an overreach.

If the final shipping Orion has just plastic or glass, the experience won't be the same, and Orion 2, which may still cost as much as a laptop will be yet another wearable AR disappointment.

@techradar

♬ original sound - TechRadar

You might also like

Lance Ulanoff
Editor At Large

A 38-year industry veteran and award-winning journalist, Lance has covered technology since PCs were the size of suitcases and “on line” meant “waiting.” He’s a former Lifewire Editor-in-Chief, Mashable Editor-in-Chief, and, before that, Editor in Chief of PCMag.com and Senior Vice President of Content for Ziff Davis, Inc. He also wrote a popular, weekly tech column for Medium called The Upgrade.

Lance Ulanoff makes frequent appearances on national, international, and local news programs including Live with Kelly and Mark, the Today Show, Good Morning America, CNBC, CNN, and the BBC. 

Read more
The Meta Orion glasses on a table next to a wristband and controller.
Meta Orion AR Glasses: the latest news on the game-changing prototype, and when we might see a consumer version
The Meta Quest 3 on a notebook surrounded by pens and school supplies on a desk
Leaked Meta memo teases 'half a dozen' new AI wearables, a mixed-reality push, and the return of the metaverse
Orange RayBan Meta Smart Glasses in front of a wall of colorful lenses including green, blue, yellow and pink
Meta tipped to launch Oakley smart glasses for athletes, and AR glasses in 2027
RayBan Meta Smart Glasses
Mark Zuckerberg just teased next-gen Ray-Ban smart glasses – here are 4 things I want to see
Project Moohan prototype at Samsung Galaxy Unpacked, an XR goggles headset on display in a show area
Android XR comes out swinging with our first look at Samsung Project Moohan, but the VR headset just makes me want AR glasses more
RayBan Meta Smart Glasses
Improved Meta Ray-Ban smart glasses could land in 2025 – with a much requested upgrade
Latest in Virtual Reality & Augmented Reality
Snap Spectacles 5
Latest Snap Spectacles update teases an exciting AR future that I can't wait for
Project Moohan prototype at Samsung Galaxy Unpacked, an XR goggles headset on display in a show area
Samsung's Android XR headset could avoid the Apple Vision Pro's biggest mistake, according to this leak
Vision Pro Metallica
Apple Vision Pro goes off to never never land with Metallica concert footage
The Ray-Ban Meta Coperni smart glasses
The new Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses design is an expensive disappointment
The Meta Quest Pro on its charging pad on a desk, in front of a window with the curtain closed
Samsung, Apple and Meta want to use OLED in their next VR headsets – but only Meta has a plan to make it cheap
The new limited edition Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses show a translucent design.
Ray-Ban and Meta just teased new limited-edition smart glasses – but they'll be in frustratingly short supply
Latest in Opinion
Sakata in Demon City holds a large cleaver-like weapon
Demon City on Netflix is Japan's answer to John Wick with a dash of Oldboy, and it rocks
A person typing on a laptop to check battery life
How Google's new anti-scraping measures are forcing an industry evolution
An abstract image of digital security.
Technology monitoring solutions are becoming obsolete
AI tools.
Laying the foundations for successful GenAI adoption
A person in a wheelchair working at a computer.
Why betting on Mac security could put your organization at risk
Apple CEO Tim Cook delivers remarks before the start of an Apple event at Apple headquarters on September 09, 2024 in Cupertino, California. Apple held an event to showcase the new iPhone 16, Airpods and Apple Watch models. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
The big Siri Apple Intelligence delay proves that maybe we really don't know Apple at all