If you think about it, The Rings of Power and House of the Dragon have nothing in common, so why compare them?

Still of Galadriel from The Rings of Power
(Image credit: Amazon Studios)

As soon as Amazon and HBO announced the release dates of their new fantasy behemoths, the fates of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power and House of the Dragon became entwined. To many observers, having the two dramas kick off within the space of two weeks ignited the ultimate clash of the titans, the magical world of Middle-earth facing off against the more down-to-earth brutality of Westeros.

The human race was comparing the incomparable long before social media turned everything into a debate – okay, argument – but you don’t have to dig as deep as the mines of Khazad-dûm to realize that this is an entirely fabricated confrontation. In fact, when it comes to fantasy storytelling, the two shows exist at opposite ends of an incredibly varied spectrum, and comparing them directly is as reductive (and pointless) as pitting Star Wars against Star Trek.

Just as a casual observer watching Star Trek/Wars for the first time might assume that the presence of spaceships, lasers and, well, stars mean they’re cut from the same cloth, there’s no denying the superficial similarities between the Lord of the Rings and Game of Thrones spin-offs.

Both of the new shows are set in detailed fantasy worlds, populated by characters with evocative names living in almost-familiar places. And although they’re prequels to long-established stories, neither is based on an established novel – The Rings of Power riffs off JRR Tolkien’s appendices to The Lord of the Rings, while House of the Dragon takes inspiration from George RR Martin’s ‘history’ of the Targaryen dynasty, Fire & Blood. Until House of the Dragon’s fifth episode channelled Game of Thrones via a memorable banquet, you could have also made a strong case that neither series had fulfilled its potential, their success based as much on the legacy of the respective franchises as any storytelling prowess of their own. 

Chalk and cheese – with dragons

King Viserys I shares a tender moment with Prince Daemon in his throne room in House of the Dragon episode 4

He may not carry a ring of power, but House of the Dragon's Daemon Targaryen could be as dangerous as anyone in Middle-earth. (Image credit: Ollie Upton/HBO Max)

Look closer, however, and the similarities are skin-deep, because the idea of Elves or Orcs setting up shop in Westeros is every bit as alien as Jean-Luc Picard dressing up as a Jedi, pulling out a lightsaber and babbling on about the Force on the bridge of the USS Enterprise.

At heart, The Lord of the Rings is a story of hope, the idea that there are some really bad things live in Middle-earth, but that good will ultimately triumph – even if it has to wait a few thousand years for victory. Notions of heroes and villains are clearly delineated, in a world where magic and immortality are commonplace (if you’re an Elf, at least), and most problems can be solved by completing a good old-fashioned quest.

In contrast, the A Song of Ice and Fire novels that inspired Game of Thrones were heavily influenced by The Lord of the Rings but – unlike a hefty chunk of the many fantasy authors who followed in JRR’s wake – Martin’s storytelling revels in subverting Tolkien tropes. Westeros is a realm of shades of (very dark) gray morality, where magic is in short supply, few things are as dangerous as your fellow humans, and noble intentions are as likely to get you killed as save the world.

Where The Rings of Power has a broader, more family-friendly appeal, House of the Dragon’s frequent, liberal depiction of NSFW content ensures it’s fantasy for grown-ups. Indeed, aside from the occasional dragon – showrunner Ryan Condal claims there are 17 of them in the new show – House of the Dragon arguably shares as much DNA with the more real-world drama of The Tudors or Succession as it does with The Rings of Power

A broad church

Star Trek: The Next Generation

Running around with lightsabers would not be tolerated on the USS Enterprise-D.  (Image credit: CBS)

Star Trek and Star Wars are rarely forced to compete in the same way as these new fantasy shows have been, possibly because everyone realizes that – whether or not phasers are set to stun – it could never be a fair fight. The final frontier could never hope to compete with a galaxy far, away when it comes to edge-of-the-seat thrills, box-office power, and “slap it on a lunchbox” pop-culture appeal, while Trek has the undoubted edge in terms of versatility and inventive storytelling.

Star Trek and Star Wars have proved over decades, however, that there’s more than one way to run a successful space-faring sci-fi franchise, so – rather than dispatching The Rings of Power and House of the Dragon into some phony war for viewing figure – we should be celebrating the fact they’re so different.

TV fantasy is becoming an increasingly broad church, where the more traditional likes of Netflix’s The Witcher and Amazon’s The Wheel of Time will soon be joined by Disney Plus’s unashamedly family-focussed Willow. Netflix’s Shadow and Bone has already taken fantasy away from the Western European/medieval blueprint that’s been dominant in the genre since the days of Tolkien, with a design aesthetic inspired by Tsarist Russia. And that‘s just the tip of the iceberg when compared to literary fantasy where – for example – writers such as RF Kuang and Tasha Suri are basing their worlds on China and India, respectively. Expect TV to follow suit.

It's all fantasy, of course, but pitting such disparate shows against each other is likely to be as fruitless as deciding whether Lionel Messi or Cristiano Ronaldo are the best soccer player of their generation. Let’s just be happy there are two hotly anticipated, mega-budget fantasy shows on TV at the same time, and keep the battles where they work best – on screen.

New episodes of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power debut on Prime Video on Fridays. New episodes of House of the Dragon are available on HBO/HBO Max (US) on Sundays, and Sky Atlantic/Now TV (UK) on Mondays.

Richard Edwards

Richard is a freelance journalist specialising in movies and TV, primarily of the sci-fi and fantasy variety. An early encounter with a certain galaxy far, far away started a lifelong love affair with outer space, and these days Richard's happiest geeking out about Star Wars, Star Trek, Marvel and other long-running pop culture franchises. In a previous life he was editor of legendary sci-fi and fantasy magazine SFX, where he got to interview many of the biggest names in the business – though he'll always have a soft spot for Jeff Goldblum who (somewhat bizarrely) thought Richard's name was Winter.

Read more
Moiraine using her magic in The Wheel of Time season 3
The Wheel of Time season 3 proves that Amazon's Lord of the Rings TV show isn't the only high fantasy heavyweight worth watching on Prime Video
A collage image showing pictures from X-Men 97, Squid Game season 2, and Fallout season 1
The 50 best shows of 2024: TechRadar's top TV picks of the year on Netflix, Prime Video, Max, Disney Plus, and more
Disappointed by The Electric State? Here's 4 reasons you should watch Tales From the Loop on Prime Video
Two phones side by side with the Netflix and Apple TV Plus apps displayed
Netflix vs Apple TV Plus: which streaming service is the most entertaining?
Three people stand inside a spaceship wearing suits
Prime Video could be removing my favorite sci-fi show this week – here’s why The Expanse is more than just Game of Thrones in space
Elayne, Egwene, and Nynaeve dressed regally and on horseback in The Wheel of Time season 3
'There's a reason why we do it': The Wheel of Time showrunner responds to fans who are still upset over the Prime Video show's plot alterations
Latest in Entertainment
Trinity Rodman #2 of the Washington Spirit crosses the ball during a game between Bay FC and Washington Spirit at Audi Field on November 10, 2024 in Washington, DC.
National Women's Soccer League 2025: How to watch NWSL games live from anywhere
Irish boxer TJ Doheny receives an undercard bout, ahead of the WBO super welterweight world title fight in March, 2023
Ball vs Doheny live stream: how to watch the boxing from anywhere now, full undercard, start time, weigh-in results
Bruno Guimaraes of Newcastle United during the Carabao Cup Semi Final Second Leg match in February 2025
Liverpool vs Newcastle live stream: how to watch Carabao Cup final 2025 online, team news
The Russo brothers posing for a photograph and Herman carrying a Volkswagen camper van in The Electric State
'We're optimists': AI enthusiasts Joe and Anthony Russo defend its use in movies and TV shows, but admit there are 'very real dangers' around its application
Lando Norris driving around a bend during practice for the 2025 Australian Grand Prix
Australian Grand Prix 2025: How to watch this season’s first F1 race online from anywhere
A collage of Tom Holland's unmasked Spider-Man and Sadie Sink's Max in Stranger Things season 4
Marvel reportedly casts Stranger Things star Sadie Sink in Spider-Man 4, but I don't want her to tackle the roles she's rumored to play
Latest in Features
Disappointed by The Electric State? Here's 4 reasons you should watch Tales From the Loop on Prime Video
A computer file surrounded by red laser beams
Cover your tracks: the risk of sending unencrypted files
Close up of PS5 DualSense controller leaning on a PS5
5 reasons your PS5 needs a VPN
Anora sitting on Ivan's lap in a casino in her self-titled film, one of the best new Hulu movies in March 2025
5 new Prime Video movies with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes I think you should stream in March
Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2
With discounts of up to 95%, these are the biggest deals I've managed to find in the Steam Spring Sale
The cast of The Parenting
The Parenting is Max's #1 most-watched movie but it has frightening reviews – here are 3 better horror films with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes