WD Black P40 Game Drive review: speed comes at a price

WD Black P40 Game Drive: One-minute review

The WD Black P40 Game Drive is an external SSD geared towards gamers. It’s compatible with PlayStation, Xbox, and PC and offers impressively fast file transfer speeds. Just bear in mind that, as an external storage device, if you intend to use this drive with a PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, or Xbox Series S, you won’t be able to run current-generation releases directly from it - only store them Still, it’s an extremely compelling game storage solution if you don’t want to have to wait too long to copy your desired games back to your console.

It boasts a sleek and modern design that’s extremely compact and impressively durable, covered in a slick layer of black aluminum that makes it easy to recommend if you’re looking for a drive specifically to take out and about. It even features colorful RGB lighting, which is an excellent touch.

That said, there are some major drawbacks to choosing an external SSD like this over an external hard drive. Firstly, there's the matter of the price. The WD Black P40 Game Drive is available in 500GB, 1TB, and 2TB capacities. While the 500GB model is the most affordable, its limited size means it’s ill-suited to storing most large, modern games. That means you’re left with the 1TB and 2TB models, which are both substantially more expensive than a hard drive. 

You can even find 5TB gaming hard drives, like the Seagate FireCuda, that come in a little cheaper than the 1TB WD Black P40 Game Drive. While a hard drive would be much slower, it is still a better option for those purely focused on getting the most storage at the lowest cost. 

WD Black P40 Game Drive: Price and availability

• 500GB costs $99.99 / £78.99 
• 1TB costs $129.99 / £135.84 
• 2TB costs $219.99 / £247.40 

The WD Black P40 Game Drive is available in three capacities: 500GB, 1TB, and 2TB. As a rule of thumb, you should avoid the 500GB model as that space is going to fill up extremely quickly. Instead, pick the 1TB model, which costs $129.99 / £135.84, or 2TB model, which is $219.99 / £247.40. Both of these are readily available at Amazon in the US and UK. They also frequently receive substantial discounts, so consider waiting for a sale before making your purchase.

WD Black P40 Game Drive: Specs

WD Black P40 Game Drive: Design and features

The design of the WD Black P40 Game Drive is seriously sleek and impressively compact. At 4.2 x 2 x 0.51in / 106.98 x 50.82 x 13mm in size it can easily be slipped into a pocket and taken out and about. It’s very lightweight, though still feels durable thanks to its ribbed aluminum case. Unlike a traditional external hard drive, this external SSD does not feature any moving parts so it’s able to withstand the odd bump without much risk of data loss or damage. If you’re looking for an Xbox, PlayStation, or PC external storage device to take on the go, then this is easily one of the best options right now.

While the top of the drive is relatively plain, adorned with a white WD Black logo and some basic model information, its underside is home to two small RGB strips. These illuminate with an eye-catching rainbow by default, but can be further customized or disabled entirely with the WD Black Dashboard software on PC.

The software is easy to use and there’s an impressive range of presets available, including support for Razer Chroma RGB, Asus Aura Sync, and more. It’s a fantastic suite of options for a storage device and makes it easy to find a look that perfectly matches your existing setup.

The drive connects to your system through a Type-C port with an included 11in / 300mm Type-C cable. A handy USB Type-A to Type-C adapter is also included in the box, so you don’t need to worry if you’re working with a limited number of free Type-C ports.

Console owners should be aware that, as an external storage device, this drive cannot play any PS5 or Xbox Series games installed on it. It can be used to play PS4 and Xbox One titles via backwards compatibility, however, where it performs well.

Seagate Game Drive for PS5: Performance

The overall performance of WD Black P40 Game Drive is significantly faster than an external hard drive, though not too remarkable compared to other external SSDs. On PS5, transferring a 90.23GB installation of Alan Wake 2 took 8 minutes and 3 seconds - less than half the time it took on the competing Seagate Game Drive for PS5. The PS4 version of Dishonored 2, which comes in at 67.21GB, was playable from the drive in just 4 minutes 23 seconds.

Hatsune Miku: Project Diva Future Tone and add-on that totalled 38.30GB transferred in 2 minutes 32 seconds. The Alone in the Dark remake, which is 30.67GB, took 2 minutes and 43 seconds. A slightly smaller PS4 game, Mirror’s Edge Catalyst, copied in an impressive 1 minute 8 seconds. Transfer time became almost negligible when it came to much smaller titles, with the 7.31GB Stray copying over in just 43 seconds and the 1.63GB Angry Birds Star Wars taking just 7 seconds.

On PC, the drive averaged a read speed of 1,048.90 MB/s and a write speed of 978.68 MB/s in a 32GB sequential test using CrystalDiskMark 8.0.5. This was on the lower end of the advertised sequel read and write speeds of up to 2,000MB/s and 1,950MB/s respectively, but did not noticeably impact performance when used to play a selection of PC games during my testing.

I did note, however, that the WD Black P40 Game Drive has a tendency to become very hot to the touch over periods of extended use. While this is unlikely to affect console users copying the odd game or two, those on PC looking to frequently transfer large files (such as video) should be aware of the potential for reduced speeds due to thermal throttling.

Should I buy the WD Black P40 Game Drive?

Buy it if...

Don't buy it if...

Also consider...

Want some alternatives to the WD Black P40 Game Drive? These two external hard drives are cheaper picks that are a perfect fit for consoles.

Seagate Game Drive for PS5
The Seagate Game Drive for PS5 is an excellent choice for PlayStation players. It’s compatible with PS5 and PS4 and offers larger capacities than the WD Black P40 Game Drive for much lower prices.

For more information, check out our full Seagate Game Drive for PS5 review

Toshiba Canvio Flex  
Those on Xbox or PC should consider the Toshiba Canvio Flex. This external hard drive is slower than the WD Black P40 Game Drive but comes in at a much more affordable price, particularly in its 1TB capacity.

For more information, check out our full Toshiba Canvio Flex review

How I tested the WD Black P40 Game Drive

• Used for one week 
• Tested with a PS5, Xbox Series S, and PC 
• Compared to other storage devices 

I tested the 500GB model of the WD Black P40 Game Drive for a week. During that time it became my go-to external storage device on PC, PS5, and Xbox Series S. On consoles, I transferred a range of games in order to measure the time that it would take to copy a game in an average scenario. 

On PC, I played games that were installed directly on the drive including Counter-Strike 2 and Last Epoch to see whether there were any noticeable performance issues. I also tested the drive using a range of benchmarks in CrystalDiskMark 8.0.5 and carefully evaluated the features of the compatible WD Black dashboard software. 

Read more about how we test

First reviewed August 2024.