Blu-ray continues to dominate HD DVD in US

Blu-ray (as played by Pioneer's BDP-LX70) is supported by a larger number of high-profile manufacturers

The Blu-ray high-definition disc format is continuing to dominate over its HD DVD rival in the United States. Home Media Research said yesterday that the Sony-backed Blu-ray format sold twice as many movies as Toshiba's HD DVD standard in the first half of 2007.

Blu-ray discs, which have a larger capacity than HD DVD ones, clocked up 1.6 million sales between January and July, with HD DVD only managing 795,000.

But while the Blu-ray Disc Association will tell you that selling 800,000 more discs than HD DVD is a big deal, it's not quite so significant as you might think.

Standalone HD player sales are still routed firmly in the low thousands in the US, which is tiny in comparison to the 85 million US households that own a normal DVD player. Hundreds of millions of DVD movies are bought and sold every year, so 800,000 is a fairly insignificant number.

War of HD attrition

Indeed, it's probably safe to say that HD discs as a whole have yet to truly fire consumers up in the US - or anywhere. The PlayStation 3 accounts for the majority of the Blu-ray players sold, and there's no guarantee that PS3 owners are actually watching Blu-ray movies on them. Without the Sony games console, Blu-ray software sales look significantly slimmer.

In Europe, HD DVD's cheaper retail prices are enabling it to sell far more standalone players than the Blu-ray camp. But again, the Blu-ray equipped PS3 is keeping Sony's soldiers in the game. Expect this handbaggy war of insignificant numbers to continue for a long time yet.

The HD war is still too early to call.

TOPICS
James Rivington

James was part of the TechRadar editorial team for eight years up until 2015 and now works in a senior position for TR's parent company Future. An experienced Content Director with a demonstrated history of working in the media production industry. Skilled in Search Engine Optimization (SEO), E-commerce Optimization, Journalism, Digital Marketing, and Social Media. James can do it all.

Latest in Blu-ray
The movie Punch-Drunk Love playing a TV, with a logo saying Blu-ray Bounty
3 new 4K Blu-rays to add to your collection from February 2025
4K Blu-ray action movies splayed out on a kitchen counter
Movie sales – including 4K Blu-ray – fell again last year, but if you're going streaming only, you're massively missing out
The Wild Robot on Panasonic MZ1500 screen with Blu-ray Bounty logo in bottom right
3 new 4K Blu-rays to add to your collection in January 2025
4K Blu-ray action movies splayed out on a kitchen counter
I love 4K Blu-ray and although 2024 was a rollercoaster year to be a fan, I'm hopeful for 2025
Godzilla (1954) image of buildings on OLED TV
4 new 4K Blu-ray discs to add to your collection in December 2024
blu-ray disc in player drive
Bad news, Blu-ray fans: LG just discontinued its entire range of 4K Blu-ray players and I’m really worried
Latest in News
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 5080 resting on an RTX 5090 on a gray crafting mat.
Corsair tells us only one of its prebuilt PCs with an RTX 5000 GPU has suffered from chip-level fault, suggesting it’s as rare as Nvidia claimed
Fujfilm GFX 50R
First Fujifilm GFX100RF images leaked in build-up to expected reveal – here’s what they tell us about the unique premium compact camera
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 6 in blue
The Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 7 could have a Motorola Razr-style full-sized cover screen – and I think it’s about time
Spotify logo on a mobile device
Had Spotify problems recently? It's clamped down on Premium APK 'modded' apps – here's what's happening
An AMD Radeon RX 9070 XT made by Sapphire on a table with its retail packaging
Last-minute AMD RX 9070 XT stock rumors are making me hopeful for a much better launch than Nvidia’s RTX 5000 GPUs – with just one snag
eSIM
Global eSIM shipment volume surpasses half a billion units as demand keeps on growing