Forget virtual reality - Microsoft's Surface Laptop shows it lives in another dimension

At Microsoft’s #MicrosoftEDU event, CEO Satya Nadella waxed lyrical about the importance of ‘democratising education’ by making technology – and educational tools – available to any student throughout the world.

This is a worthy vision, one where no matter what a child’s background, they will not be left behind while more fortunate students benefit from expensive technology, and by showing off a lightweight Windows 10 S operating system, alongside affordable $189 devices made by third parties, I was almost sold.

But then things went a bit wrong. Microsoft began talking about virtual reality and mixed reality and how essential to learning they will become, and I began questioning what reality Microsoft lived in.

How could VR replace textbooks?

I know many teachers who are even more passionate about teaching, and making sure their students all have an equal chance of learning, than Microsoft.

They work long hours, they complain about outdated textbooks, budget cuts and the struggle to engage students. None of them have ever said that putting a HoloLens in a classroom would solve that.

Microsoft showed footage of classrooms full of these expensive augmented reality headsets. When teachers in the real world worry that some of their students can’t afford school meals every day. 

Do they really think equipping a classroom with one (or more) $3,000 (£2,720, AU$4,370) headsets is going to be a priority?

Microsoft said that teachers can create lesson plans in AR, draw up immersive, interactive, 3D displays to wow the children. When a teacher has already spent hours after work continuing to mentor and help children, where are they going to have the time to do that? Who will teach the teachers to create these lessons?

How much?!

And then came the announcement of the Surface Laptop. When the rumors emerged this morning, some people (including myself) thought that maybe Microsoft had created an affordable laptop that would target Chromebooks, with a bit of polish and build quality Microsoft’s hardware is known for.

A Chromebook-killing Microsoft device that gave students the opportunity to have a rock-solid machine that lasted them their entire time at school or university, while offering more flexibility than the pared-down Chrome OS software, was a genuinely exciting prospect.

And then Microsoft announced the hardware. It soon became clear that Microsoft was not targeting affordable Chromebooks, but expensive and premium MacBooks. Surface boss Panos Panay boasted about how much more powerful the Surface Laptop is compared to a MacBook. 

And then came the price.

For the ‘cheapest’ hardware configuration, Microsoft is asking for $999 (about £773, AU$1,328). That’s a huge price tag that in the real world many students just can’t afford. Microsoft’s Panos Panay spoke about how Microsoft wanted to make a device for everyone, but at that price, it’s a device for hardly anyone.

Apple has the same problem – making products that just don’t target the reality of many students around the world. At least Apple has a desirable brand image that makes some people think that paying extra for a MacBook is worth it. In Microsoft’s Redmond bubble, it’s assumed people are just as enthusiastic about it. 

They are not.

I’m sure that the Surface Laptop will be a wonderful and well-built device, but by suggesting it’s a device most students will want, it shows how out of touch Microsoft actually is.

Matt Hanson
Managing Editor, Core Tech

Matt is TechRadar's Managing Editor for Core Tech, looking after computing and mobile technology. Having written for a number of publications such as PC Plus, PC Format, T3 and Linux Format, there's no aspect of technology that Matt isn't passionate about, especially computing and PC gaming. He’s personally reviewed and used most of the laptops in our best laptops guide - and since joining TechRadar in 2014, he's reviewed over 250 laptops and computing accessories personally.

Latest in Windows Laptops
Asus Vivobook S laptop on yellow background with price cut text overlay
I've looked through hundreds of laptop deals in the Spring sales - this $599 Asus Vivobook has them all beat
The Surface Laptop 7 on a cyan background with a TechRadar deals badge.
This Windows laptop is 31% off in Amazon's Spring Sale and we scored it 5 stars – so why is Amazon putting a warning label on it?
The Microsoft Surface Laptop on a blue background with text saying Lowest price next to it.
The Microsoft Surface Laptop is our best-rated model and right now it's close to half price with this massive $700 discount
Dell XPS 13 Laptop in graphite on yellow background with big savings sign
Save $400 on the top-rated Dell XPS 13 - one of the best laptops money can buy
The Samsung Galaxy Book4 Pro on a blue background next to text saying Don't Miss.
This half-price Samsung Galaxy Book4 Pro is easily the best Presidents' Day laptop deal
Microsoft Surface Pro on a blue background
Best Buy has a huge $350 discount on this excellent high-end Surface Pro bundle
Latest in News
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con up-close from app store
Nintendo's new app gave us another look at the Switch 2, and there's something different with the Joy-Con
cheap Nintendo Switch game deals sales
Nintendo didn't anticipate that Mario Kart 8 Deluxe was 'going to be the juggernaut' for the Nintendo Switch when it was ported to the console, according to former employees
Three angles of the Apple MacBook Air 15-inch M4 laptop above a desk
Apple MacBook Air 15-inch (M4) review roundup – should you buy Apple's new lightweight laptop?
Witchbrook
Witchbrook, the life-sim I've been waiting years for, finally has a release window and it's sooner than you think
Amazon Echo Smart Speaker
Amazon is experimenting with renaming Echo speakers to Alexa speakers, and it's about time
Shigeru Miyamoto presents Nintendo Today app
Nintendo Today smartphone app is out now on iOS and Android devices – and here's what it does