Civilization designer: Why gamers' expectations defy reason

Civilization designer Sid Meier says you cannot do enough to please the player in the first 15 minutes of a game
Civilization designer Sid Meier says you cannot do enough to please the player in the first 15 minutes of a game

Civilization designer and veteran god game developer Sid Meier gave one of the final keynote speeches at this years' Games Developers Conference in San Francisco, explaining his thoughts on what drives his players and how his thinking on player psychology has changed over time.

Meier talked of the "unholy alliance" between the player's suspension of disbelief and the designer's willingness to defy both logic and the laws of maths to satisfy the player's expectations.

"A lot of what I thought I knew was wrong," said the Civilization designer. "And the reason was because I really hadn't taken into account what really happens in the player's game."

Can't reward the player enough

Meier, the Director of Creative Development at Firaxis Games, stressed that it is crucial to give players the feeling of winning and to make the first 15 minutes "really compelling, really fun - almost a foreshadowing of all the cool stuff that's going to happen later in the game.

"These rewards are really a way of making the player feel comfortable in this world, of letting them know they're on the right track.… You can almost not reward the player enough in the early stages of the game.

"Players are very much inclined to accept anything you give them gladly and feel it was their own clever play, their own incredibly strategy that earned them that cool reward. On other hand, if something bad happens to the player, your game is broken, there's something horribly wrong, the game is cheating. It's really important to be very careful with the setbacks the player experiences."

Meier revealed that Civilization originally had a "rise and fall" arc, so players would build a civilization, experience disaster, and come back mightier than ever. That was soon dropped because:

"What we found was, just at the cusp of the crumble, most players would reload a save game. They would never experience the glorious rerise that we had in mind for them."

Via Edge

Adam Hartley
Latest in Gaming
Cristiano Ronaldo promotional image for Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves
Yes, Cristiano Ronaldo is a playable character in Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves, and it makes more sense than you think
inZOI.
inZOI early access won't feature Denuvo DRM after all, 'we are committed to making inZOI a highly moddable game'
Nintendo Music teaser art
Nintendo Music expands its library with songs from Kirby and the Forgotten Land and Tetris
EA Sports F1 25 promotional image featuring drivers Oscar Piastri, Carlos Sainz and Oliver Bearman.
F1 25 has been officially announced, with this year's entry marking a return for Braking Point and a 'significant overhaul' for My Team mode
Nintendo Direct live blog.
Nintendo Direct live build-up: no Switch 2, but these are our predictions for what we could see
A price cut on the PDP Victrix Pro BFG for Xbox.
The brilliant PDP Victrix Pro BFG is my choice when it comes to Xbox controllers, and is currently massively discounted at Amazon
Latest in News
A PC gamer celebrating, sat in a gaming chair in front of a monitor
Windows 11’s Game Bar gets a fresh coat of paint, plus a tweak to work better on handhelds – and I like the direction Microsoft’s heading in here
NHS
NHS IT supplier hit with major fine following ransomware attack
A business woman looking at AI on a transparent screen
Most businesses are now fully embracing AI - but aren't always protected against the risks
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge on display the January 22, 2025 Galaxy Unpacked event.
All three rumored Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge colors shown off in ‘official’ images
Cristiano Ronaldo promotional image for Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves
Yes, Cristiano Ronaldo is a playable character in Fatal Fury: City of the Wolves, and it makes more sense than you think
inZOI.
inZOI early access won't feature Denuvo DRM after all, 'we are committed to making inZOI a highly moddable game'