Week In Gaming: When is a game not really a game?

Week In Gaming

Some games are not games, but no one really cares

It's a strange argument, and one that comes around with the regularity of a news story involving politicians and sexual deviancy: some video games are being marketed as video games when they (gasp) might not be. The argument is strange because there isn't really a proper definition of video game yet - it's a medium in its infancy, relative to things like music, film and books. In fact, when films first started out, they were silent and in black and white - but that doesn't mean that all films have to be that way. Some books are choose-your-own-adventure books, and others - like graphic novels - are almost entirely pictures, yet you can still find them in bookshops, and the world hasn't stopped turning because of that

So why is there so much agonising over what does and doesn't constitute a "video game"? Eurogamer attempted to address the issue recently, with Aoife Wilson discussing Her Story, Journey and Gone Home amongst others in her search for what constitutes a "game".

"I find it so weird that every time a title that experiments even just a little bit with the traditional gaming format comes along, there are people that so desperately need to reclassify it," she says in her video. "These arguments are about as useful as arguing whether soup is a food or a drink." Aoife hits the nail on the head - basically, who cares?

But with comments sections, social media and forums open to anyone with an opinion and a keyboard, these non-issues become issues purely because of the vocal minority that think "games" ought to be a protected category. The reason people complain is simple: they are attempting to invalidate experiences that they find irrelevant to them by dismissing them as nonsense; as visual novels; as something that doesn't deserve to share the same hallowed genre as their beloved shooters and RPGs.

The issue, then, is not that these people are dismissive of the games in particular, but that they are dismissive of the topics those games cover. Consider Her Story, a passively-told tale that stars only one actor: a woman. Or Gone Home, a sleepy game that has you reading diary entries and little else. Or Journey, or Flower, or Proteus - any one of a number of games who have had that "Not-A-Game" label thrown at them - all of which have a few things in common: they are leisurely, player-driven and often have little or nothing in the way of plot, conflict and combat.

If that's what constitutes a game, then the industry is doomed to stagnate. Indies are more exciting, ambitious and creative than ever, freed from the pressure of publishers and huge budgets - they don't need to have guns, knives and half-naked women in them to tell their story. Most people I know welcome these games in with open arms, writing about them on websites and in magazines that traditionally cover games (like Eurogamer, IGN and Gamespot), and the only reason we should really care about whether or not they are games is to ensure that these places still get to write interesting and engaging pieces on them.


But really, the only point that can come out of a column like this, or anything that attempts to dip into the utterly tiring topic of "what is a game", is: who bloody cares? Just enjoy what you enjoy, and stop telling other people that they're not allowed to enjoy things because you don't. You plonkers.

Latest in Consoles & PC
Image of Naoe in AC Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows is hands-down one of the most beautiful PC ports I've ever seen
Image of AC Shadows cover art & Steam Deck
It's not perfect, but Assassin's Creed Shadows' performance is impressive - it runs smoothly on the Steam Deck and Asus ROG Ally
Steam Deck OLED in limited edition white color
With a single update SteamOS could turbocharge handheld PCs – here's how
Samus Aran leaping through space
Metroid Prime 4 tipped to be at the heart of April's Nintendo Switch 2 deep-dive
Nintendo Switch 2
Nintendo Switch 2 expected to have AI upscaling and I can't wait to finally play Tears of the Kingdom with upgraded graphics
Asus ROG Ally using Steam
I think Asus could be the perfect partner for an Xbox handheld – but I have questions
Latest in News
DeepSeek
Deepseek’s new AI is smarter, faster, cheaper, and a real rival to OpenAI's models
Open AI
OpenAI unveiled image generation for 4o – here's everything you need to know about the ChatGPT upgrade
Apple WWDC 2025 announced
Apple just announced WWDC 2025 starts on June 9, and we'll all be watching the opening event
Hornet swings their weapon in mid air
Hollow Knight: Silksong gets new Steam metadata changes, convincing everyone and their mother that the game is finally releasing this year
OpenAI logo
OpenAI just launched a free ChatGPT bible that will help you master the AI chatbot and Sora
An aerial view of an Instavolt Superhub for charging electric vehicles
Forget gas stations – EV charging Superhubs are using solar power to solve the most annoying thing about electric motoring