BBC: ISP traffic management 'is a worrying development'

BBC discusses the future of the web
BBC discusses the future of the web

The BBC has outlined its stance on net neutrality in a blog this week, explaining that a trend towards traffic management by UK ISPs is "worrying".

Erik Huggers, Director, BBC Future Media & Technology, says in the blog – which is titled 'Net neutrality and the BBC' – that: "the BBC recognises that traffic management may sometimes be necessary for technical reasons – for example to cope with legitimate network congestion.

"But this should be the exception. An emerging trend towards network operators discriminating in favour of certain traffic based on who provides it, as part of commercial arrangements, is a worrying development."

Traffic discrimination

The reason Huggers and the BBC believe that traffic management is "worrying" is because it could cause a two-tier internet.

"For companies that can pay for prioritisation, their traffic will go in a special fast lane," notes Huggers.

"But for those that don't pay? Or can't pay? By implication, their traffic will be de-prioritised and placed in the slow lane.

"Discriminating against traffic in this way would distort competition to the detriment of the public and the UK's creative economy."

While this isn't a new argument it is interesting to see the BBC take measures to make sure that traffic management doesn't become a problem.

Putting the web at risk

In the blog Huggers stated that the BBC has spoken to Ofcom and the European Commission about the situation.

"This innovative and dynamic ecosystem, that enables huge public value, could be put at risk if network operators are allowed to use traffic management to become gatekeepers to the internet," notes Huggers.

The BBC is becoming more and more reliant on ISPs, this is due to the sheer popularity of the iPlayer.

Because of this, the BBC has a vested interest in making sure that all users of the iPlayer have the best experience with the service and are not stifled by web bandwidth.

Marc Chacksfield

Marc Chacksfield is the Editor In Chief, Shortlist.com at DC Thomson. He started out life as a movie writer for numerous (now defunct) magazines and soon found himself online - editing a gaggle of gadget sites, including TechRadar, Digital Camera World and Tom's Guide UK. At Shortlist you'll find him mostly writing about movies and tech, so no change there then.

Latest in Computing
ChatGPT vs. Manus
I compared Manus AI to ChatGPT – now I understand why everyone is calling it the next DeepSeek
Vision Pro Metallica
Apple Vision Pro goes off to never never land with Metallica concert footage
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 on a table with its retail packaging
Nvidia RTX 5060 GPU spotted in Acer gaming PC, suggesting rumors of imminent launch are correct – and that it’ll run with only 8GB of video RAM
cyberpowerpc gamer supreme gaming PC on orange background with don't miss text overlay
I've looked through all the available RX 9070 XT pre-builts and this is the gaming PC I'd buy with my own cash
Image of Asus VU34WCIP monitor
Asus might have just changed the display game for good with three new air-purifying monitors - and one of them is ultrawide
An AMD Radeon RX 9070 XT made by Sapphire on a table with its retail packaging
Want to buy an RX 9070 or 9070 XT but fed up of the GPUs being out of stock? AMD promises that “more supply is coming ASAP”
Latest in News
Vision Pro Metallica
Apple Vision Pro goes off to never never land with Metallica concert footage
Mufasa is joined by another lion, a monkey and a bird in this promotional image
Mufasa: The Lion King prowls onto Disney+ as it finally gets a streaming release date
An American flag flying outside the US Capitol building against a blue sky
Sean Plankey selected as CISA director by President Trump
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060 on a table with its retail packaging
Nvidia RTX 5060 GPU spotted in Acer gaming PC, suggesting rumors of imminent launch are correct – and that it’ll run with only 8GB of video RAM
Indiana Jones talking to a friend in a university setting with a jaunty smile on his face
New leak claims Indiana Jones and the Great Circle PS5 release will come in April
A close up of the limited edition vinyl turntable wrist watch from AndoAndoAndo
This limited-edition timepiece turns the iconic Technics SL-1200 turntable into a watch, and I want one