Digital Economy Bill 'a catastrophic disaster'

Anger as anti-piracy bill is rushed through parliament in the 'wash-up' before the general election
Anger as anti-piracy bill is rushed through parliament in the 'wash-up' before the general election

MPs in the House of Commons have passed the controversial Digital Economy Bill, despite accusations of a "stitch up" and former minister Tom Watson calling the bill a "catastrophic disaster".

The bill is an attempt to tackle the growing problem of illegal file-sharing online, but has come under a lot of criticism for promoting a 'three strikes' style penalty system for persistent offenders, whereby ISPs are required to police and – potentially – cut off their own customers.

Copyright holders will then also be able to apply for a court order to get the names and addresses of persistent filesharing offenders.

A catastrophic disaster

Former minister Tom Watson said the bill was a "catastrophic disaster" as it stands.

"There might be a deal with the Tory front bench and the Lib Dem front bench but there are 20,000 people who have taken the time to e-mail their MPs about this in the last seven days alone," Mr Watson said of the proposals.

"They are extremely upset that this bill will not have the scrutiny it deserves and requires."

The bill was approved by MPs by a majority of 142 votes and is now with the House of Lords for final approval.

The legislation is one of over 10 bills being considered by the government in what is called the "wash-up period" - the remaining time before the legislature is dissolved before a general election.

Culture Secretary Ben Bradshaw said of the bill that: "Hundreds of millions of pounds every year is currently haemorrhaging from our creative industries because of unlawful file-sharing.

"This is not a harmless or victimless activity. It deprives our musicians, writers and film makers and other artists of their livelihoods and if we don't do something about it, it will pose a serious threat to our creative sectors and Britain's in them."

Via the BBC

Adam Hartley
Latest in Computing
girl using laptop hoping for good luck with her fingers crossed
Windows 11 24H2 seems to be a massive fail – so Microsoft apparently working on 25H2 fills me with hope... and fear
ChatGPT Advanced Voice mode on a smartphone.
Talking to ChatGPT just got better, and you don’t need to pay to access the new functionality
Grok Image Edits
I tried Grok’s new AI image editing features – they’re fun but won’t replace Photoshop any time soon
AI hallucinations
We're already trusting AI with too much – I just hope AI hallucinations disappear before it's too late
Google Gemini AI
Gemini can now see your screen and judge your tabs
Girl wearing Meta Quest 3 headset interacting with a jungle playset
Latest Meta Quest 3 software beta teases a major design overhaul and VR screen sharing – and I need these updates now
Latest in News
girl using laptop hoping for good luck with her fingers crossed
Windows 11 24H2 seems to be a massive fail – so Microsoft apparently working on 25H2 fills me with hope... and fear
ChatGPT Advanced Voice mode on a smartphone.
Talking to ChatGPT just got better, and you don’t need to pay to access the new functionality
Insecure network with several red platforms connected through glowing data lines and a black hat hacker symbol
Multiple H3C Magic routers hit by critical severity remote command injection, with no fix in sight
Apple Watch Ultra 2 timer
The Apple Watch is getting a sleep alarm upgrade it probably should have had 10 years ago
Nikon Z5
The Nikon Z5 II could land soon – here's what to expect from Nikon's rumored entry-level full-frame camera
An abstract image of a lock against a digital background, denoting cybersecurity.
Critical security flaw in Next.js could spell big trouble for JavaScript users