People are unhappy with Facebook's plan for free internet, but why?

Facebook drone
Facebook wants to bring the web everywhere.

Poor Mark Zuckerberg - all he wanted to do was bring internet connectivity to the people of the world that didn't have it, and sign them up for Facebook at the same time - but the protests against his plans are getting louder and more vehement.

A new open letter and petition says the project "violates the principles of net neutrality, threatening freedom of expression, equality of opportunity, security, privacy, and innovation". Ouch.

One of the problems is that Internet.org provides access to a limited number of whitelisted sites rather than the web as a whole. That means new users connecting in developing nations won't have access to the full breadth of the web.

A not-so-level playing field

Another sticking point is the 'zero rating' plan, where some sites can be used for free without it counting against a user's data plan. This makes it easier for poorer communities to access portals like Wikipedia but essentially promotes certain sites above others, which is contradictory to net neutrality principles.

Security and privacy are two other concerns mentioned in the open letter: will data be collected on the millions of new users coming online? And will they be aware of the information they're giving up? These are the questions Facebook is being asked to answer.

67 rights groups have put their names to the petition up until now. In a response sent to the BBC, Facebook said the aim was to get people online for free before giving them access to the wider web once they've seen the benefits it could bring.

David Nield
Freelance Contributor

Dave is a freelance tech journalist who has been writing about gadgets, apps and the web for more than two decades. Based out of Stockport, England, on TechRadar you'll find him covering news, features and reviews, particularly for phones, tablets and wearables. Working to ensure our breaking news coverage is the best in the business over weekends, David also has bylines at Gizmodo, T3, PopSci and a few other places besides, as well as being many years editing the likes of PC Explorer and The Hardware Handbook.

Latest in Facebook
The Meta logo on a smartphone in front of the Facebook logo a little bit blurred in the background
Meta's new 'Link History' feature for the Facebook app isn't as protective of your data as it claims
The Meta Quest 3 in action
How much more data can Meta collect? Probably a lot, thanks to the Meta Quest 3 and Ray-Ban smart glasses
A laptop screen showing a Facebook Groups page
Scam alert: how to spot hoax posts in your Facebook Groups
Facebook
Facebook Messenger is losing a useful messaging feature soon
mother watching her daughter's activity online
Meta's new Facebook parental controls show social media still doesn't like responsibility
Phone screen closeup showing the download page for the Facebook app in the app store.
Meta wants to create a Facebook app store to compete with Apple's App Store and Google Play
Latest in News
YouTube TV
YouTube TV might be planning a big Netflix update that puts the best streaming services first
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Here are the 7 best Pixel 9 and Pixel Watch 3 features landing in March’s Pixel Feature Drop
Bang & Olufsen Beogram 4000C Saint Laurent Rive Droite Edition
Bang & Olufsen's latest reworked turntable is a masterpiece of retro revival, in a breathtaking wooden presentation box
Apple Watch Series 10
Apple unveils new Apple Watch bands – here's what's in the Spring 2025 collection
iPad Air M3
Apple makes one hardware change to the iPad Air that might be the best indicator of its true lightweight tablet intentions
Shure MoveMic 88+ lifestyle image
Shure's tiny MoveMic 88+ gives creators a cheap and easy way to record crystal clear audio on a smartphone