UK Government's snooping bill to be rewritten after mass criticism

Government's snooping bill roundly damned by review, Lib Dems, Labour
The Home Office: "La la la, we're not listening"

The Government's draft communications bill, which would give it and the police greater access to what you've been up to online, is to be re-drafted after a review found it wanting.

After a huge amount of pre-legislative scrutiny carried out by MPs and Peers from all the UK's major political parties, the proposed bill was roundly damned in its current form.

A spokesperson for the prime minister said that Number 10 accepts the criticisms and will re-write the Bill.

He said, "We recognise this is a difficult issue. We will take account of what the committee said."

What the committee said

The Draft Communications Data Bill wants to force ISPs to store the who, when and where of all online activity, including email, instant messaging, social media activity, web browsing and VoIP calls for a year.

The police, Serious Organised Crime Agency, HM Revenue and Customs and the Home Office would be able to access this data, although the Home Office would have to grant a warrant to police.

The committee found that the draft Bill shows "insufficient attention to the duty to respect the right to privacy, and goes much further than it need or should".

It also criticised the Home Office's failure to consult with internet firms and said that predicted costs of £1.8 billion are far too low.

Lord Blencathra, chair of the joint committee, explained that UK citizens should not be made to feel like Big Brother and the Thought Police are watching them.

He said, "There is a fine but crucial line between allowing our law enforcement and security agencies access to the information they need to protect the country and allowing our citizens to go about their daily business without a fear, however unjustified, that the state is monitoring their every move."

Omnishambles

As well as the obvious privacy concerns associated with ISPs storing your every online move for a year, deputy prime minister Nick Clegg slammed the cost of the project and the ratio of crime-fighting security to people's civil liberties.

He threatened to block the Bill if it wasn't rewritten, saying, "The coalition government needs to have a fundamental rethink about this legislation. We cannot proceed with this bill and we have to go back to the drawing board."

Labour agreed, with shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper telling the BBC that the government is "making a complete mess of a very important issue".

All sides concede that the security implications are important, but as Cooper puts it, "this bill is too widely drawn, is unworkable and gives far too much power to the home secretary without proper safeguards".

She added that the ISPs and other internet firms (like Twitter) have been little involved: "It is astonishing that the Home Office have had so little discussion with the internet companies who need to deliver this legislation."

Other bodies welcoming the Joint Committee's findings include the Open Rights Group and the Internet Services Providers' Association (ISPA).

Disregard

Despite the backlash, the Tories are still pretty gung ho on the whole thing.

Home Secretary Theresa May, who is pushing the Bill hardest of all, grossly oversimplified the matter by telling The Sun, "Criminals, terrorists and paedophiles will want MPs to vote against this bill. Victims of crime, police and the public will want them to vote for it. It's a question of whose side you're on."

A Home Office spokesperson added, "This legislation is vital to help catch paedophiles, terrorists and other serious criminals and we are pleased both scrutiny committees have recognised the need for new laws.

"We have now considered the committees' recommendations carefully and we will accept the substance of them all. But there can be no delay to this legislation. It is needed by law enforcement agencies now."

"There can be no delay" did not sound very promising vis-à-vis rewriting the bill as per the committee's recommendations, but it looks as though May has been overruled.

The prime minister's spokesman did not give any indication of a timeline for the bill's second draft but it seems unlikely that it will make it to parliament for consideration before late 2013.

News Editor (UK)

Former UK News Editor for TechRadar, it was a perpetual challenge among the TechRadar staff to send Kate (Twitter, Google+) a link to something interesting on the internet that she hasn't already seen. As TechRadar's News Editor (UK), she was constantly on the hunt for top news and intriguing stories to feed your gadget lust. Kate now enjoys life as a renowned music critic – her words can be found in the i Paper, Guardian, GQ, Metro, Evening Standard and Time Out, and she's also the author of 'Amy Winehouse', a biography of the soul star.

Latest in Internet
Google Maps on a phone being held in someone's hand
Google Maps is getting two key upgrades, for easier route planning and quicker access to Gemini AI
Quordle on a smartphone held in a hand
Quordle hints and answers for Thursday, March 27 (game #1158)
NYT Strands homescreen on a mobile phone screen, on a light blue background
NYT Strands hints and answers for Thursday, March 27 (game #389)
Pinterest
How to post on Pinterest
Quordle on a smartphone held in a hand
Quordle hints and answers for Wednesday, March 26 (game #1157)
NYT Strands homescreen on a mobile phone screen, on a light blue background
NYT Strands hints and answers for Wednesday, March 26 (game #388)
Latest in News
Garmin clippd integration
Garmin's golf watches just got a big software integration upgrade to help you improve your game
Robert Downey Jr reveals himself as Doctor Doom to a delighted crowd at San Diego Comic-Con 2024
Marvel is currently making a major announcement about Avengers: Doomsday's cast on YouTube, and I think it's going to be a long-winded reveal
Samsung QN90F on yellow background
Samsung announces US prices for its 2025 mini-LED TV lineup, and it’s good and bad news
Nintendo Switch Lite
Forget the Nintendo Switch 2, the original Switch is getting one last hurrah in a surprise Nintendo Direct tomorrow
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge on display the January 22, 2025 Galaxy Unpacked event.
Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge colors seemingly revealed in new video, and there’s another sign of an imminent launch
Microsoft Copiot Studio deep reasoning and agent flows
Microsoft reveals OpenAI-powered Copilot AI agents to bosot your work research and data analysis