UK Govt is unwelcome Facebook friend

Facebook believes the government's plans are "overkill"
Facebook believes the government's plans are "overkill"

Most people wouldn't want their parents looking at their status updates, let alone the government, but plans are afoot for the UK's intelligence services to monitor the public's web communications.

The idea is being proposed by the Home Office, and is part of the government's plan to monitor and log all phone calls, emails and websites visited on a central database.

This would mean that your Facebook, MySpace and BeBo friends would be logged. Considering around 50 per cent of the UK is on a social-networking site, that's a lot of information,

Deeply worrying

Speaking to ZDnet, Facebook's Chief Privacy Officer is unsurprisingly unhappy with the plans and believes it's too excessive.

"We think monitoring all user traffic is overkill. There is legislation to allow law enforcement access to traffic data [of suspects]. We are not convinced at this time that expansion of those channels is necessary."

He continued: "One of the reasons that Facebook has been so successful is that it provides greater privacy controls than any other [social-networking service] on the internet.

"The privacy controls allow people to share information in a comfortable, safe and trusted environment. We are not convinced at this time that expansion of those channels is necessary."

The Independent spoke to Liberal Democrat MP Tom Brake about the database, which has been dubbed a 'snoopers' charter', and he is also wary of the government's plans: "It is deeply worrying that they now intend to monitor social networking sites which contain very sensitive data like sexual orientation, religious beliefs and political views."

No interest from government

When the BBC spoke to the Home Office, however, a spokesperson played down the social-networking aspect of the proposal, saying: "The government has no interest in the content of people's social network sites and this is not going to be part of our upcoming consultation.

"We have been clear that the communications revolution has been rapid in this country and the way in which we collect communications data needs to change, so that law enforcement agencies can maintain their ability to tackle terrorism and gather evidence."

This is despite Home Office secretary Verne Coaker saying last week that there were plans to keep hold of traffic data for all messages on social-networking sites, including Facebook, MySpace, and Bebo, as part of the government's Intercept Modernisation Programme (IMP).

Marc Chacksfield

Marc Chacksfield is the Editor In Chief, Shortlist.com at DC Thomson. He started out life as a movie writer for numerous (now defunct) magazines and soon found himself online - editing a gaggle of gadget sites, including TechRadar, Digital Camera World and Tom's Guide UK. At Shortlist you'll find him mostly writing about movies and tech, so no change there then.

Latest in Facebook
 Facebook social media app logo on log-in, sign-up registration page
How to delete all your Facebook posts
The Meta logo on a smartphone in front of the Facebook logo a little bit blurred in the background
Meta's new 'Link History' feature for the Facebook app isn't as protective of your data as it claims
The Meta Quest 3 in action
How much more data can Meta collect? Probably a lot, thanks to the Meta Quest 3 and Ray-Ban smart glasses
A laptop screen showing a Facebook Groups page
Scam alert: how to spot hoax posts in your Facebook Groups
Facebook
Facebook Messenger is losing a useful messaging feature soon
mother watching her daughter's activity online
Meta's new Facebook parental controls show social media still doesn't like responsibility
Latest in News
Zotac Gaming RTX 5090 Graphics Card
Nvidia Blackwell stock woes are compounded by price hikes as more RTX 5090 GPUs soar in pricing, and I’m sick and tired of it all at this point
An Apple Music pink/pixellated poster advertising DJ with Apple Music
DJ with Apple Music lands, allowing subscribers to build and mix DJ sets directly from its +100 million-song catalog
The Meta Quest 3 and controllers on their charging station which is itself on a wooden desk next to a lamp
Forget Android XR, I've got my eyes on Vivo's new Meta Quest 3 competitor as it could be the most important VR headset of 2025
Samsung Galaxy S25 from the front
The Now Bar on Samsung One UI 7 is about to get a lot more useful – and could soon match Live Activities on iOS
Marvel Rivals
Marvel Rivals will get two new hero skins for Moon Knight and Black Panther this week meaning I'll now need to farm even more Units
Nvidia app
Tired of manually optimizing your games? Nvidia's new G-Assist could save you time