Judge dismisses claims Facebook, Google had secret digital advertising pact

judge hammer
(Image credit: Pixabay)

A federal judge in the US has cleared Facebook and Google of collusion in relation to an online marketing deal between the two companies, while allowing the ongoing antitrust case against the latter to continue. 

As reported by The Verge, Judge P. Kevin Castel claimed the “Jedi Blue” deal broke no laws because of “Facebook’s motivation to use its economic clout as an advertising to drive the hardest bargain it could, and that Google was motivated by the legitimate, pro-competitive desire to obtain as much business as possible from Facebook.”

The agreement involved Facebook avoiding “header bidding”, a practice that allows companies to run their own auctions for ad space, in return for higher placement in Google’s own advertising listings. 

But in simple terms, the pact was not considered collusion because both companies were seen to have acted in their own separate interests.

Google’s antitrust woes

Although both companies have been cleared of legal wrongdoing, the renewed spotlight on the Jedi Blue deal - first brought to light via another antitrust lawsuit filed against Google by a number of US states in 2020 - has highlighted the control that a small number of large tech companies have over online content advertising.

In an online blog post, Google claimed that the dismissal of accusations of collusion around the Jedi Blue deal proved that this latest antitrust case, led by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, is “deeply flawed”. It also claimed that “much” of the case has now been ruled in its favor.

However, the tech giant isn’t in the clear just yet. Judge Castel’s ruling deferred Google’s claim for dismissal -  on the grounds that the states that filed the case waited too long to do so- until later in the proceedings. He also wrote that the states have “plausibly alleged” that a number of Google’s practices within its operation of ad servers and ad exchanges are anti-competitive.

One of these practices was Google’s secret operation of “Project Bernanke”, a program that generated hundreds of million dollars in revenue for Google over several years by using previous bid data from the company’s ad exchanges to give itself an advantage over competitors, making it easier for Google to win bids at ad auctions.

Google is no stranger to antitrust lawsuits, either. The US Department of Justice filed an antitrust case against the company in 2020, and is reportedly looking to file again after building the case over a number of years that Google's parent company Alphabet Inc. has monopolized the field of digital content marketing (via Bloomberg). 

In its first complaint, the DOJ wrote that “American consumers are forced to accept Google’s policies, privacy  practices, and use of personal data; and new companies with innovative business models cannot emerge from Google’s long shadow.”

TOPICS
Luke Hughes
Staff Writer

 Luke Hughes holds the role of Staff Writer at TechRadar Pro, producing news, features and deals content across topics ranging from computing to cloud services, cybersecurity, data privacy and business software.

Read more
Google Chrome logo on a mobile phone's screen
Google asks US government to drop breakup plan over national security fears
Chrome icon on Android
The US government still wants Google to sell off Chrome
Europe
Apple and Meta set to face fines for alleged breaches of EU DMA
Sam Altman and OpenAI
UK regulator clears Microsoft’s $13bn deal with OpenAI after lengthy delay
Microsoft
Microsoft hits back against UK competition lawsuits, slams AWS and Google once again
 In this photo illustration, the big tech companies Google, Apple, Meta, Amazon, Microsoft logos seen displayed on a mobile phone screen.
Big tech needs less than three weeks to pay off over $8 billion in 2024 fines
Latest in Software & Services
woman listening to computer
AWS vs Azure: choosing the right platform to maximize your company's investment
Autonomous finance
Quickbooks vs Quicken: what are the main strengths and weaknesses for your business
finance
Quickbooks vs Xero: which is the best for your business?
Group of people meeting
Zoom vs Google Meet: which is the best video conferencing tool for your business?
Fingers typing on a computer keyboard.
Microsoft 365 Personal vs Microsoft 365 Family: are there any real differences?
Person at laptop
Windows 11 vs Windows 365: which is the best choice for businesses?
Latest in News
A super close up image of the Google Gemini app in the Play Store
It's official: Google Assistant will be retired for phones this year, with Gemini taking over
Quordle on a smartphone held in a hand
Quordle hints and answers for Sunday, March 16 (game #1147)
NYT Strands homescreen on a mobile phone screen, on a light blue background
NYT Strands hints and answers for Sunday, March 16 (game #378)
NYT Connections homescreen on a phone, on a purple background
NYT Connections hints and answers for Sunday, March 16 (game #644)
Three iPhone 16 handsets on show
Apple could launch an iPhone 17 Ultra this year – but we've heard these rumors before
Super Mario Odyssey
ChatGPT is the ultimate gaming tool - here's 4 ways you can use AI to help with your next playthrough