Newegg reverses 'open box' return policy following Gamers Nexus scandal

MSI Z490
(Image credit: MSI)

PC retail giant Newegg has suddenly reversed a long-standing return policy after an incident with a popular YouTube channel, and will now accept all returns on "open box" products on a "no questions asked" basis.

Gamers Nexus posted a video earlier this month called “Newegg Scammed Us,” detailing a purchase with Newegg gone terribly wrong.

According to the video, Gamers Nexus site owner Steve Burke purchased a $500 open box Z490 motherboard from Newegg that he decided to return upon its delivery. He initiated an RMA with the site, which was eventually rejected due to an “apparent end-user caused physical damage to the CPU socket contact pins.”

Burke pointed out that the box was never opened, making this claim impossible, which sparked another statement from the support team claiming that thermal paste was found on the board. Gamers Nexus went public with the incident and Newegg decided to refund him as well as send him back the motherboard he originally bought.

However, Burke discovered a hand-written RMA ticket from Gigabyte from a technician taped to the motherboard. It revealed that the motherboard had been previously sent by Newegg to Gigabyte to be RMA’d, then was sent back to Newegg unfixed. This meant that it now had the open box label and, aware of this, Newegg still shipped it to Burke.

Gamers Nexus took to Twitter with this new development and asked its followers for any similar tales concerning the online retail giant. Once the stories started pouring in, Newegg finally relented and announced its policy change with Windows Central and on Twitter.

Via ExtremeTech

Allisa James
Computing Staff Writer

Named by the CTA as a CES 2023 Media Trailblazer, Allisa is a Computing Staff Writer who covers breaking news and rumors in the computing industry, as well as reviews, hands-on previews, featured articles, and the latest deals and trends. In her spare time you can find her chatting it up on her two podcasts, Megaten Marathon and Combo Chain, as well as playing any JRPGs she can get her hands on.

Read more
The RTX 4070 FE graphics card being held aloft by a grizzled hand in the pits of hell.
Buyer beware: Asus' Q-Release Slim feature is reportedly damaging GPUs like the RTX 5090
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 5080 resting on an RTX 5090 on a gray crafting mat.
Corsair tells us only one of its prebuilt PCs with an RTX 5000 GPU has suffered from chip-level fault, suggesting it’s as rare as Nvidia claimed
The RTX 5090 imprint on the Nvidia GeForce RTX 5090
Rumors that RTX 5090 GPU review models are somehow faster than retail boards are shot down by Nvidia
NVIDIA GeForce RTX 50 Series image
RTX 5090 and 5080 GPU stock woes could be eased as Nvidia launches 'priority access' scheme to help genuine buyers and leave scalpers in the cold
An RTX 5090 sitting on top of its retail packaging against a green background
Nvidia confirms 'rare issue' with some RTX 5090 and RTX 5070 Ti GPUs – here’s how to check if you’re affected and to get a replacement
ASUS ROG Astral LC GeForce RTX 5090 OC Edition liquid cooled graphics card against a blue background
Get ready to pay $1360 more for the RTX 5090 - Asus just raised prices yet again, and AMD's RX 9070 XT is also affected
Latest in Motherboards
MSI's four available motherboard sizes
Motherboard sizes explained: which should you buy in 2025?
Asus X870 motherboard quick release PCIe slot with a graphics card being removed
Hate those five-minute battles to remove your graphics card? Painful GPU extraction woes could be a thing of the past with new motherboards
AMD X870 and X870E motherboards
AMD announces new X870 and X870E motherboards for new Ryzen 9000 CPUs
Gigabyte motherboards
Leak shows Gigabyte motherboards for Intel Arrow Lake CPUs pack some kind of mysterious AI feature
Processor socket and ram memory slots on a MSI MAG Z490 TOMAHAWK gaming motherboard
What is a motherboard: your computer's foundation explained
shiba inu meme with the Asus and AMD logos
Asus does what AMD doesn't: honoring warranties for motherboards blown out by Ryzen 7000 chips
Latest in News
Perplexity Squid Game Ad
New ad declares Squid Game's real winner is Perplexity AI
Pedro Pascal in Apple's Someday ad promoting the AirPods 4 with Active Noise Cancellation.
Pedro Pascal cures his heartbreak thanks to AirPods 4 (and the power of dance) in this new ad
Frank Grimes confronts Homer Simpson in The Simpsons' Homer's Enemy episode
Disney+ adds a new continuous Simpsons stream, so you no longer have to spend ages choosing an episode
Helly and Mark standing on an artificial hill surrounded by goats in Severance season 2 episode 3
New Apple teaser for Severance season 2 finale suggests we might finally find out what Lumon is doing with those goats, and I don't think it's anything good
Nvidia GR00T N1 humanoid robot
Nvidia is dreaming of trillion-dollar datacentres with millions of GPUs and I can't wait to live in the Omniverse
Foldable iPhone
Apple’s first foldable iPhone could beat the Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 7 in one key way