Apple to be sued for 'closed' iTunes store

iTunes is in breach of Norweigan law
iTunes is in breach of Norweigan law

Apple's decision to keep the majority of its iTunes store accessible only to those who have an iPod, has come under fire by a consumer watchdog in Norway.

The Norwegian consumer group is threatening to sue the company as 'closing off' iTunes to other MP3 players means that Apple is in breach of consumer laws in Norway.

A spokesperson for the group, Bjoern Erik Thon, said: It's a consumer's right to transfer and play digital content bought and downloaded from the internet to the music device he himself chooses to use.

"iTunes makes this impossible or at least difficult, and hence they act in breach of Norwegian law."

The decision to take Apple to court isn't a rash one, as talks between the company and the watchdog have been on-going but ultimately, er, fruitless.

No progress

The last time the groups met up to discuss the problem with iTunes was in February of this year, but despite some tentative talks nothing came of the meeting, says Thon:

"In February 2008, the Consumer Ombudsman met with iTunes in Berlin. Here, iTunes underlined that they wanted to sell music without DRM-technology, and that they shared the Consumer Ombudsman's aim of full interoperability in the online music market.

"No progress has been reported by iTunes since our meeting in February 08. The consumer's freedom of choice in the online music market is an important right. This is a matter of great principal importance."

Apple has until 3 November to put its case forward to the Market Council.

TOPICS
Marc Chacksfield

Marc Chacksfield is the Editor In Chief, Shortlist.com at DC Thomson. He started out life as a movie writer for numerous (now defunct) magazines and soon found himself online - editing a gaggle of gadget sites, including TechRadar, Digital Camera World and Tom's Guide UK. At Shortlist you'll find him mostly writing about movies and tech, so no change there then.

Latest in Wi-Fi & Broadband
Eero 7 on a nightstand
Amazon's new Eero 7 and Pro 7 complete a 'comprehensive lineup' for its customers – here's everything you need to know
A hacker wearing a hoodie sitting at a computer, his face hidden.
I just learned something awful about my home Wi-Fi setup thanks to iFixit’s ‘worst of CES 2025’ awards
Extendable WiFi 7 KV
Don't buy a router, buy a fast and secure ASUS WiFi 7 extendable router
Netgear Nighthawk router next to its box on a table
Netgear Nighthawk RS200 review: Netgear’s latest Wi-Fi 7 router is competitively priced – but makes compromises to get there
Netgear Orbi 770 router system resting on a table
Netgear Orbi 770 review: fast speeds, low Wi-Fi 7 prices
TP-Link Deco X55 3 pack
Don’t wait until Black Friday to fix your Wi-Fi – this awesome Labor Day deal could solve your problems
Latest in News
A hand holding a phone showing the Android Find My Device network
Android's Find My Device can now let you track your friends – and I can't decide if that's cool or creepy
Insta360 X4 360 degree camera without lens protector
Leaked DJI Osmo 360 image suggests GoPro and Insta360 should be worried – here's why
A YouTube Premium promo on a laptop screen
A cheaper YouTube Premium Lite plan just rolled out in the US – but you’ll miss out on these 4 features
Viaim RecDot AI true wireless earbuds
These AI-powered earbuds can also act as a dictaphone with transcription when left in their case
The socket interface of the Intel Core Ultra processor
Intel unveils its most powerful AI PCs yet - new Intel Core Ultra Series 2 processors pack in vPro for lightweight laptops and high-performance workstations alike
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 5070
Nvidia confirms that an RTX 5070 Founders Edition is coming... just not on launch day