Apple refused to negotiate 3G licenses, according to Samsung

Apple allegedly refused to negotiate on 3G patents its iPhone violated
Apple allegedly refused to negotiate on 3G patents

There are more patent issues brewing in the ongoing case between Samsung and Apple, as accusations fly that Apple refused to enter into a licensing agreement for its 3G tech.

For those keeping score, the accusation comes out of the Australian case between the two technology giants.

In July 2011, Apple filed for patent infringement due to touch screen technology used in the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1.

In response, Samsung filed a countersuit claiming that Apple's iPhone 4, 4S and iPad 2 were in violation of three of its 3G technology patents.

Samsung getting its days in court

The latter case is finally getting its day in court, as hearings began by discussing two of the 3G data transmission patents.

In Samsung's remarks, the company's attorney Neil Young expressed that Samsung attempted to enter into fair negotiations for the infringed patents, but Apple wouldn't play nice.

"Our position is Apple has refused to engage in negotiations," Young said.

The hearings are scheduled to continue through the end of the week, with hearings for the third 3G patent taking place in October.

The Australian suit is one of many cases taking place worldwide as the technology titans clash.

Samsung recently won a bittersweet victory in a case against Apple determining that the Galaxy Tab line is not an iPad copycat on the grounds that "they are not as cool" as Apple's tablet.

As a result, Apple now must advertise a retraction online and in newspapers saying that the Galaxy Tab did not copy the iPad.

Apple is garnering more favor in the U.S., where a California court determined to place a ban on Galaxy Nexus smartphones and the Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet. The court then refused Samsung's request to postpone the decision and appeal the ban.

The long-running legal proceedings are far from over though, as Apple still alleges Samsung is in violation of eight patents across 17 of its devices, with those hearings still to come.

TOPICS
Latest in iPhone
Two hands holding the Tecno Spark Slim phone
The world’s thinnest phone was just revealed, but a new iPhone 17 Air leak suggests it could be even slimmer
Apple iPhone 16e on blue background
This week's best Apple iPhone 16e deals: where to get the latest iPhone for cheap
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
Leaked iPhone 17 schematics show the Apple phones could be getting a speaker redesign
Apple iPhone 16e REVIEW
The iPhone 16e doesn’t have MagSafe, but apparently Apple thinks you didn’t want it anyway
Apple iPhone 16 Pro on purple background with price cut text overlay
Verizon's best iPhone 16 Pro deal is back - get a free phone, iPad, and Apple Watch without a trade
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
The iPhone 17 Pro could come with 12GB of RAM to help it power though AI tasks
Latest in News
Google Gemini iPhone Lock Screen
You can now access Gemini from your iPhone's lock screen
Michelle, Keats, and Doctor Amherst looking unimpressed and worried in The Electric State
Netflix drops trailer for The Electric State, and I'm getting serious District 9 vibes
YouTube TV
YouTube TV might be planning a big Netflix update that puts the best streaming services first
Google Pixel 9 Pro
Here are the 7 best Pixel 9 and Pixel Watch 3 features landing in March’s Pixel Feature Drop
Bang & Olufsen Beogram 4000C Saint Laurent Rive Droite Edition
Bang & Olufsen's latest reworked turntable is a masterpiece of retro revival, in a breathtaking wooden presentation box
Apple Watch Series 10
Apple unveils new Apple Watch bands – here's what's in the Spring 2025 collection