Judge orders Oracle, Google to disclose paid bloggers and journalists

Gavel
Oracle/Google judge lays down the law

One last bit of fireworks are bursting in a Google-Oracle patent lawsuit that was, until now, seemingly decided and done with.

Both Google and Oracle have been ordered to disclose any financial relationships they made with bloggers, journalists and other writers – essentially, anyone either company paid to publicly discuss the case.

"Although proceedings in this matter are almost over, they are not fully over yet...the disclosure required by this order would be of use on appeal or on any remand to make clear whether any treatise, article, commentary or analysis on the issues posed by this case are possibly influenced by financial relationships to the parties or counsel," wrote U.S. District judge William Alsup his ruling Tuesday.

Google has said it plans to comply with the order; Oracle, however, sees this as a sort-of victory, albeit one that's likely pyrrhic, given how Oracle faired in all phases of the civil trial.

"Oracle has always disclosed all of its financial relationships in this matter, and it is time for Google to do the same," said Oracle's Deborah Hellinger in a statement.

"We read this order to also include indirect payments to entities who, in turn, made comments on behalf of Google."

Detailing the suit

The "copyright portion" of Oracle's suit, the first such portion put to a jury test over the use of Java within Android, ended in a hung jury.

Alsup ultimately ruled that Google's use of Java APIs constituted fair use - in other words, Google didn't violate Oracle's copyrights.

As for the trial's second phase, its "patent portion," the jury unanimously found that Google did not infringe two of Oracle's patents by shooting down six of Oracle's claims on U.S. Patent No. RE38,104 and two claims on U.S. Patent No. 6,061,520.

While Google was found to have copied nine lines of code from Oracle – within 15 million lines of code for the Android operating system – Oracle and Google agreed that the companies wouldn't exchange any money as a result.

Oracle still plans to appeal the results of the rulings to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Determining disclosure

As for the new "disclosure portion" of the case, Oracle and Google have until August 17 to comply with Alsup's order.

However, a number of pundits and legal scholars are keeping a close eye on how this ruling pans out – mostly because Alsup's move is rather unprecedented.

"I can't say it's impossible that there are some constitutional issues here, but I'm struggling to figure out what they would be," said Paul Alan Levy, an attorney with the Public Citizen Litigation Group.

Additionally, issues surrounding just how wide a range of individuals Alsup's ruling might cover could turn up more names than intended once Google and Oracle submit their final lists – do legitimately independent journalists whose sites benefit from Google Adwords count?

Right now, however, the general tech world is buzzing at the thought of who might be on Google or Oracle's payroll – under the radar, of course.

Via The Verge, ReadWriteWeb, Ars Technica and Business Insider

TOPICS
Latest in Phones
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
The iPhone 17 Air looks impressively slim in this new comparison image, but that just makes me more worried about the specs
Two Android phones on a green and blue background showing Google Messages
Google Messages just added a fun upgrade to one of its best chat features
Samsung Galaxy S25 on a blue deals background
Bored with your iPhone? The ‘incredible’ Samsung Galaxy S25 just hit a record-low price in the Amazon Spring Sale
Samsung Galaxy S25 from the front
The Now Bar on Samsung One UI 7 is about to get a lot more useful – and could soon match Live Activities on iOS
An iPhone running iOS 18 on a purple and blue background
iOS 18.4 could launch soon with a major upgrade to your iPhone’s notifications
Google Pixel 9a being held, from the back
The Google Pixel 9a’s mysterious delay may have just been explained
Latest in News
Ransomware
Cl0p resurgence drives ransomware attacks to new highs in 2025
Millwall FC The Den
The UK's first football club mobile network is here - but you probably won't guess which team has launched it
The Witcher 4
You're probably not playing The Witcher 4 until 2027 at the earliest, per CD Projekt's latest financial update
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
The iPhone 17 Air looks impressively slim in this new comparison image, but that just makes me more worried about the specs
Matt Murdock smiling in Daredevil: Born Again episode 5 and Kamala Khan looking stunned in The Marvels
Daredevil: Born Again episode 5 just revealed what Kamala Khan has been up to since The Marvels, and now I'm more excited for the next superhero team to appear in the MCU
Google Pixel Watch 3, 41mm and 45mm
Google says it will fix broken Wear OS 5.1 update, but why does this keep happening?