Phones4U administrators accuse operators of plot to destroy retailer

gavel
(Image credit: Shutterstock / Anton27)

Administrators acting on behalf of Phones4U have accused several of the UK’s leading mobile operators of breaching antitrust legislation, claiming collusion between them led to the demise of the mobile phone retailer in September 2014.

Phones4U generated revenues of £1 billion and a profit of £130 million during 2013, but entered administration just twelve months later after losing supply agreements with all four major operators.

Three withdrew in 2012, and is not a target of the lawsuit, while O2 ended its arrangement in April 2014, followed by EE and Vodafone five months later.

At the time, Phones4U said the latter two terminations were a shock as both companies had indicated they were interested in long-term relationships.

Phones4U claims the three operators were not working independently but engaged in unlawful coordination. Lawyers representing the administrators alleged that the aim was to reduce the volume of business done through Phones4U because of low profit margins in the UK.

Orange and Deutsche Telekom, which joint-owned EE before it was bought by BT for £12.5 billion in 2016, Telefonica, which merged O2 with Virgin Media last year, and Vodafone all deny the allegations.

The closure of Phones4U left Carphone Warehouse as the sole independent mobile phone retailer on the high street. Parent company Curry’s has since closed all of its standalone Carphone Warehouse stores, renegotiated contracts with operators, and increased its online presence to capture more of the market.

Comparison websites have become increasingly common sales channels, while mobile operators have invested significantly in their own physical and online retail operations.

Via FT

Steve McCaskill is TechRadar Pro's resident mobile industry expert, covering all aspects of the UK and global news, from operators to service providers and everything in between. He is a former editor of Silicon UK and journalist with over a decade's experience in the technology industry, writing about technology, in particular, telecoms, mobile and sports tech, sports, video games and media. 

Read more
Vodafone
Vodafone sells Italian business for €8 billion
Assorted streaming apps are seen on an iPhone, including Netflix, Prime Video, Max, Disney+, Hulu, YouTube TV, Sling TV, Paramount+, Apple TV, Peacock, fuboTV, Philo, DirecTV, tubi, Pluto TV, and Plex
UK CMA opens investigations into Apple and Google mobile ecosystems
HPE Juniper Networks acquisition deal
US Justice Department sues to block billion-dollar HPE-Juniper deal
Browser
The future of mobile browsers: time for a new model?
Arm
Arm may be planning to hike prices, has considered developing its own chips
Vodafone logo outside a store in Sydney
Vodafone employees could lose bonuses if they’re not in office 8 days per month
Latest in Phone & Communications
GlocalMe KeyTracker
When I tested this global tracker, it trounced the Apple AirTag in so many ways
Privacy Hero II
Privacy Hero II VPN Router
ThinkPhone 25 by Motorola
I reviewed the ThinkPhone 25 by Motorola and while it's not as fast as its predecessor, it's the superior phone in so many ways
FRITZ!Box 7690 WiFi 7 Router
FRITZ!Box 7690 router review
Ulefone Armor Pad 4 Ultra Thermal
Ulefone Armor Pad 4 Ultra Thermal rugged tablet review
Unihertz Tank Pad 8849
Unihertz Tank Pad 8849 rugged tablet review
Latest in News
Pro-Ject A1.2 in black, playing a vinyl record in a hi-fi listening room
Pro-Ject's new fully-automatic turntable could be the buy of Record Store Day 2025
Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet
Intergalactic: The Heretic Prophet reportedly won't release until after 2026, as Neil Druckmann says that staff 'are playing it at the office' right now - but I don't think I can wait that long
Screenshot from action RPG soulslike Lies of P
Lies of P Overture won't elaborate on the game's eyebrow-raising post-credits twist, and I think that's good news
Nintendo Switch 2
The Switch 2 launching with a Mario Kart game 'is very unlike Nintendo' compared to the original Switch releasing with Breath of the Wild, says former marketing leads: 'That's what's gonna make you want to buy the new hardware'
Kindle de Amazon
The latest Kindle update finally fixes page turning – and adds the perfect reading tool for my sieve-like brain
Waze voice control
Waze is ditching Google Assistant for Gemini on iOS, and for good reasons