Does anyone really need a digital medium format camera?

Pentax 645Z sensor
There's a 54MP sensor inside Pentax's medium format digital camera

When I first got in to photography, which wasn't quite 100 years ago, there were three reasonably clear groups of camera user. The happy snappers used compacts, the enthusiasts used SLRs and the professionals used medium, or large, format. If you were a really 'serious' amateur, and every club had at least one of these Yodas, you might have got yourself a medium format system, using 6x4.5cm, 6x6cm or even 6x7cm frames of 120 roll film.

If you were a professional wedding or landscape photographer you wouldn't have dreamt of using a 35mm SLR, for credibility reasons as much as for quality, and a happy snapper wouldn't have known which end of a 35mm SLR or medium format camera to look through.

Not much of that has meant a great deal in the last eight or so years, and the lines between what is professional equipment and what is amateur are exceedingly blurred. These days a first timer can pick up a DSLR, switch it to auto, and be shooting in minutes, while exceedingly few non-professionals own a medium format camera. Indeed, exceedingly few professionals own anything other than a DSLR, and have to attempt to distinguish themselves and their professionalism with better techniques and better lighting.

Old format, old hat

It would be easy to believe that the medium format concept is out-dated and that it has perhaps had its day - passed over for more nimble and flexible systems. With reflection though, we might recognise that it was a lack of kit at an affordable price that forced the medium format camera off the shopping lists of the nation's serious photographers, not a lack of desire for what a medium format camera can achieve.

In the meantime, many of us have forgotten what medium format means and what medium format can do. I think we all remember that when pixel counts are equal, a pixel on a full-frame sensor is larger than a pixel on an APS-C sensor, which in turn is bigger than a pixel on a compact camera sensor. In general, we appreciate that larger pixels are better than smaller ones. It should follow then, that a pixel on a medium format sensor of that same pixel count will be bigger and better again. So the image quality from a 24-million-pixel medium format camera should be proportionately better than that of a full frame camera with the same 'resolution'.

More than resolution

Crucially though, it wasn't just image quality that drew us to medium format film cameras, it was also the characteristics of the image itself - a function of that physically larger frame. We just couldn't achieve the same sort of dramatically shallow depth-of-field with a 35mm camera except with a very expensive lens that may well not perform well wide open.

Pentax 645Z

The Pentax 645Z looks a lot like a 35mm DSLR

And that advantage holds true for this new Pentax 645Z. Its draw for the creative photographer isn't so much that it has 54 million pixels with a pitch of 5.3 microns, but that its 43.8x32.8mm sensor can deliver a crisp full length portrait against a creamy background at an aberration-free f/5.6 and a distance of 15 feet. With a standard 55mm lens.

The camera's resolution is important, of course, but it probably won't be long before such pixel populations exist on smaller sensors. There will never come a time however, when a smaller sensor can better that creative selective focus, or the quality with which a medium format camera can achieve it. And with the 645Z, medium format cameras are taking a significant step towards becoming affordable.

Latest in Cameras
L-mount alliance
Sirui joins L-Mount Alliance to deliver its superb budget lenses for Leica, DJI, Sigma and Panasonic cameras
Nikon Z8 camera in the hand with 4-axis screen pulled out
We think the Nikon Z8 is the best hybrid camera for pros and it just hit a record-low price
Holding the Fujifilm GFX100 RF medium-format compact camera
Fujifilm GFX100RF preorders are live: where to buy Fuji's latest medium format compact camera
Xiaomi 15 Ultra smartphone housed in the Xiaomi Photography Kit, with user hold the phone up to take a photo outdoors
I swapped my $3,000 camera for the Xiaomi 15 Ultra for a month – here's what I learned
Canon March 2025 launch teaser
Canon teases two big vlogging camera launches for next week – and one looks to be the PowerShot V1
A Sony camera's sensor, low key lighting, dark background
Sony teases new full-frame camera unveil next week – here’s what it could be
Latest in News
Google Pixel 9
The Google Pixel 10 just showed up in Android code – and may come with a useful speed boost
L-mount alliance
Sirui joins L-Mount Alliance to deliver its superb budget lenses for Leica, DJI, Sigma and Panasonic cameras
Security padlock and circuit board to protect data
Trust in digital services around the world sees a massive drop as security worries continue
A Lego Pikachu tail next to a Pebble OS watch and a screenshot of Assassin's Creed Shadow
ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories from LG's excellent new OLED TV to our Assassin's Creed Shadow review
Samuel and Romy standing very close together in A24's Babygirl movie
Everything new on Max in April 2025, including A24's Babygirl and The Last of Us season 2
An AMD Radeon RX 9070 XT made by Sapphire on a table with its retail packaging
AMD’s secret weapon against Nvidia seems to be stock – way more RX 9070 GPUs are rumored to be hitting shelves than RTX 5000 models