Why YouTube Music hasn't replaced Google Play Music... yet

Since the launch in the US of YouTube Music, the question most people have been asking is: why isn't this a direct replacement to Google Play Music?

On paper, both apps offer similar functionality. But YouTube Music has the added bonus of being able to tap into the vast archive of YouTube for its music, as well as the videos that go alongside this.

At the UK launch of YouTube Music and YouTube Premium, TechRadar asked T Jay Fowler, head of product at YouTube, exactly that question and it's something that the company is working very hard to figure out.

It turns out there is a very good reason the apps are currently co-existing: it's all about making sure that all functionality that Google Play Music users currently enjoy is eventually ported over to YouTube Music - as it stands, this just isn't the case. 

Bringing YouTube Music and Google Play Music together

"We are working very hard to bring the two experiences together," said Fowler to TechRadar. "Supporting two apps on the market does come with some challenges and there are some beloved features in Google Play Music that we are in the process of building [into YouTube Music].

"But until we have those features we have a commitment to those users."

When it comes to the specific features, Fowler pointed out user profiles, bringing over users' playlists and, most importantly, the locker service. This is the section of Google Play Music where users upload their current music collections to the cloud, ready to stream wherever they want.

"We are working as fast as we can to bring them together," notes Fowler. 

YouTube Music and YouTube Premium have just launched in the UK and are out now in 17 countries in total, including Australia and the US.

If you are already a subscriber to Google Play Music, then you will automatically get access to YouTube Music. 

Marc Chacksfield

Marc Chacksfield is the Editor In Chief, Shortlist.com at DC Thomson. He started out life as a movie writer for numerous (now defunct) magazines and soon found himself online - editing a gaggle of gadget sites, including TechRadar, Digital Camera World and Tom's Guide UK. At Shortlist you'll find him mostly writing about movies and tech, so no change there then.

Latest in Audio Streaming
A close up of the new web version of Apple Music Classical
Apple Music Classical is now available on the web, but its Mac app is still nowhere in sight
Spotify AI DJ on a phone being held in a hand
Hey AI DJ, put a record on: Spotify seems set to let you speak to its AI DJ
Lady Gaga sat at a press conference table for Spotify's fan event
Spotify’s press conference with Lady Gaga shows that music streaming services really do think about the fans after all
Woman holding phone in field with Spotify app onscreen
The Spotify bug that shows ads to Premium subscribers has finally been fixed - for now at least
King Charles III sat at his desk in promo for his radio broadcast for Apple Music 1
Apple Music gets the royal treatment with special King Charles show – and the playlist has some real jewels
A screen shot of Lady Gaga in her interview with Zane Lowe for Apple Music
Lady Gaga’s Spotify press conference is being live streamed today – here’s where you can watch Spotify’s big step forward in fan inclusion
Latest in News
Jason Sudeikis' Ted Lasso pointing at someone in Ted Lasso season 2
Believe it, baby: Ted Lasso season 4 is officially in development for Apple TV+ – and Jason Sudeikis will reprise his role as the titular soccer coach
Rainbow Six Siege X promotional art.
The Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Siege X 6v6 mode might finally pull me away from Black Ops 6
A close up of the new web version of Apple Music Classical
Apple Music Classical is now available on the web, but its Mac app is still nowhere in sight
Silent Hill f
Silent Hill f will present players with 'a beautiful yet terrifying choice', and I can't wait to see what it is
Google Chromecast 2
Google is finally rolling out a fix for broken Chromecasts – just as new bugs appear on the Chromecast with Google TV
Garmin Instinct 3 in Neotropic Green
"I'm an idiot": Garmin user reveals how fixing one setting completely changed their training after months of making no progress