Ang Lee on high frame rate: 'People have mixed feelings right now'

Life of Pi
A scene from Ang Lee's Life of Pi

Ben Affleck may have taken home the Best Picture Oscar for Argo, but one nominee has the tech side of filmmaking buzzing weeks after the curtain at Dolby Theatre closed.

Best Director winner Ang Lee triumphed for his saga Life of Pi, and while the film failed to completely capture the Academy's heart, its immersive dose of 3D helped nab the flick a few statuettes, including Cinematography, Visual Effects and Lee's director nod. The film also grabbed Bafta honors for Cinematography and Special Visual Effects.

3D, as Pi and fellow CG film The Hobbit attest, continues to break out of the gimmicky mold some place it in and into highly regarded pieces of cinema.

Lee opened up on his thoughts on 3D and gave a cautious take on the high frame rate (HFR) format during a group interview (reported by Screen Rant) prior to the International 3D Society Awards last month.

3D future

Though filmmakers are still perfecting the modern 3D medium, Lee said he envisions a time when viewers forget they're watching a film that uses the special effect and are instead simply enjoying a movie.

"For Life of Pi, I'd like [movie watchers] to just go along with the story and not think about the 3D - as they walk out, they forget to take off their glasses," he said.

"But I think we're in a transitional time. Maybe in the future it won't have to be that way. Once we get used to it - it'll be something else."

Lee and 3D are likely to walk hand-in-hand for many films to come, perhaps even in a Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon like martial arts film down the road. Not only would the action pop, the dramatic effects of 3D are, for Lee, enticing.

HFR here to stay?

HFR, a technique that amps the number of frames used from 24 to 48, was implemented to success (from a filmmaker's perspective) in The Hobbit. "The Middle-earth picture filmed in both 3D and HFR, something that's never before been attempted.

The decision to use the rapid frame speeds greatly improved the movie's CG animation - character details were sharper and more perceptible -- according to Joe Letteri, senior visual effects supervisor for the film.

3D carried over so well into Life of Pi, it might seem a natural progression for Lee to marry it with HFR.

The director, however, is more cautious, echoing some audience concerns.

"People have mixed feelings right now," Lee said. "I wonder how much HFR is ahead of its time or people simply don't like the look. It's very hard to say.

"We associate it with 'video' looks - which people associate with bad filmmaking. It doesn't mean that the media itself is not good. It's very hard to say but making Life of Pi I struggled with frame rate because you don't want the 3D to be jittery and we're constantly rocking in the ocean.

"And sometimes when things go too fast I could not see the eyes - so HFR might be [an] idea.

"But sometimes when I find out how people feel about it, I think it's possible. We're in the early stages of 3D filmmaking - so we have a lot to learn."

Michelle Fitzsimmons

Michelle was previously a news editor at TechRadar, leading consumer tech news and reviews. Michelle is now a Content Strategist at Facebook.  A versatile, highly effective content writer and skilled editor with a keen eye for detail, Michelle is a collaborative problem solver and covered everything from smartwatches and microprocessors to VR and self-driving cars.

Latest in Tech
A Lego Pikachu tail next to a Pebble OS watch and a screenshot of Assassin's Creed Shadow
ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories from LG's excellent new OLED TV to our Assassin's Creed Shadow review
A triptych image of the Meridian Ellipse, LG C5 and Xiaomi 15.
5 amazing tech reviews of the week: LG's latest OLED TV is the best you can buy and Xiaomi's seriously powerful new phone
Beats Studio Pro Wireless Noise Cancelling Headphones in Black and Gold on yellow background with big savings text
The best Beats headphones you can buy drop to $169.99 at Best Buy's Tech Fest sale
Ray-Ban smart glasses with the Cpperni logo, an LED array, and a MacBook Air with M4 next to ecah other.
ICYMI: the week's 7 biggest tech stories from Twitter's massive outage to iRobot's impressive new Roombas
A triptych image featuring the Sennheiser HD 505, Apple iPad Air 11-inch (2025), and Apple MacBook Air 15-inch (M4).
5 unmissable tech reviews of the week: why the MacBook Air (M4) should be your next laptop and the best sounding OLED TV ever
Apple iPhone 16e
Which affordable phone wins the mid-range race: the iPhone 16e, Nothing 3a, or Samsung Galaxy A56? Our latest podcast tells all
Latest in News
FiiO FX17 IEMs
Our favorite budget audiophile brand unveils wired earbuds with 26(!) drivers, electrostatic units, USB-C ultra-Hi-Res Audio, and a not-so-budget price
girl using laptop hoping for good luck with her fingers crossed
Windows 11 24H2 seems to be a massive fail – so Microsoft apparently working on 25H2 fills me with hope... and fear
Code Skull
Interpol operation arrests 300 suspects linked to African cybercrime rings
ChatGPT Advanced Voice mode on a smartphone.
Talking to ChatGPT just got better, and you don’t need to pay to access the new functionality
Insecure network with several red platforms connected through glowing data lines and a black hat hacker symbol
Multiple H3C Magic routers hit by critical severity remote command injection, with no fix in sight
Apple Watch Ultra 2 timer
The Apple Watch is getting a sleep alarm upgrade it probably should have had 10 years ago