Judge orders Google to hand confidential user data over to FBI

crazy judge
Google may have more luck in an appeal, the judge said

A federal judge ordered Google to comply with warrantless FBI requests for confidential user data in a case that, until now, has been kept under wraps.

Google argued that the FBI's National Security Letters, electronic information requests that don't require approval from a judge, are illegal.

The search giant requested that 19 NSLs issued to it by the FBI be modified or thrown out, but U.S. District Judge Susan Illston wouldn't have it, CNET reported today.

Fortunately for Google and anyone using Google's services, that's not likely to be the end of the story.

A dangerous precedent

NSLs can be sent in secret to request data from web and tech companies as long as the data somehow relates to a national security investigation. Those who receive Letters aren't even allowed to talk about them.

They've been around since before 2001's Patriot Act, but after that they were made even broader.

If Google is forced to comply, then any of its users' data could potentially be handed over to the government if requested. In fact, that's how things currently stand, but if Google wins, then laws regarding NSLs could potentially be altered.

Illston even suggested that Google might try again to dispute the NSL requests, but with different tactics.

Fighting the system

The judge told Google that its arguments this time may have been too broad, and that the company would do better to focus specifically on why the 19 FBI requests in question in this case are illegal.

She also reserved judgment on two of the 19 requests, saying she wanted more information from the government.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals is engaged in a separate case in which it's reviewing the constitutionality of NSLs, and Illston said she's also hesitant to issue a ruling here that may interfere with that case.

Illston is also involved in that case, which was brought by the Electronic Frontier Foundation on behalf of an undisclosed telecommunications company.

  • Why's Google so concerned about privacy? The search company can give you plenty of reasons.
TOPICS
Michael Rougeau

Michael Rougeau is a former freelance news writer for TechRadar. Studying at Goldsmiths, University of London, and Northeastern University, Michael has bylines at Kotaku, 1UP, G4, Complex Magazine, Digital Trends, GamesRadar, GameSpot, IFC, Animal New York, @Gamer, Inside the Magic, Comic Book Resources, Zap2It, TabTimes, GameZone, Cheat Code Central, Gameshark, Gameranx, The Industry, Debonair Mag, Kombo, and others.

Micheal also spent time as the Games Editor for Playboy.com, and was the managing editor at GameSpot before becoming an Animal Care Manager for Wags and Walks.

Latest in Computing
Lenovo Legion 5i
It's the best time to buy an RTX 4070 gaming laptop since Black Friday - get up to $600 off on massive clearance deals
Three angles of the Apple MacBook Air 15-inch M4 laptop above a desk
Apple MacBook Air 15-inch (M4) review roundup – should you buy Apple's new lightweight laptop?
Computer memory RAM on motherboard background
How to enable XMP
David Kampf #64 of the Toronto Maple Leafs warms-up before playing the Philadelphia Flyers at the Scotiabank Arena on March 25, 2025 in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
ChatGPT and Gemini Deep Research helped me choose an NHL team to support, and now I'm obsessed with ice hockey
Person printing
Microsoft’s latest Windows 11 update exorcises possessed printers that spewed out pages of random characters
Person using a laptop.
How to check battery health of a laptop
Latest in News
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con up-close from app store
Nintendo's new app gave us another look at the Switch 2, and there's something different with the Joy-Con
cheap Nintendo Switch game deals sales
Nintendo didn't anticipate that Mario Kart 8 Deluxe was 'going to be the juggernaut' for the Nintendo Switch when it was ported to the console, according to former employees
Three angles of the Apple MacBook Air 15-inch M4 laptop above a desk
Apple MacBook Air 15-inch (M4) review roundup – should you buy Apple's new lightweight laptop?
Witchbrook
Witchbrook, the life-sim I've been waiting years for, finally has a release window and it's sooner than you think
Amazon Echo Smart Speaker
Amazon is experimenting with renaming Echo speakers to Alexa speakers, and it's about time
Shigeru Miyamoto presents Nintendo Today app
Nintendo Today smartphone app is out now on iOS and Android devices – and here's what it does