Shout at your TV all you want, Samsung doesn't care that you're watching Storage Wars

Samsung TV

This week we found out that Samsung TVs don't actually transmit voices of viewers back to HQ for analysis and forwarding to GCHQ, but that's OK because we were only pretending to be bothered about it to have something to talk about. Weren't we?

Who, in all honesty, believed the headlines that suggested our daily conversations were being uploaded to a Samsung server by our televisions?

Imagine the tedium of being the person in charge of tracking billions of daily conversations. And what would Samsung be looking for among that mine of data? Complements about the thickness of its bezels? People talking about being a bit thirsty so it can serve Coke ads? How boring the future has turned out.

It was your typical internet storm, obviously not really true if you paid attention, but possible enough that the whole online world pretended it might be so Samsung could be Social Media Enemy of the Day.

Disable EastEnders, this requires my full attention

For a few hours, though, before Samsung said it was all a case of poorly-worded terms and conditions, everyone was (only pretending to be) up in arms about the possibility that Samsung might be building the mother of all personal data mines.

Over on the Daily Mail, where people tend to think everything is true no matter how bizarre it might seem, the raging would've made North Korea proud.

Reader Bill Loni thinks it's banking data for use against us on the future, suggesting: "For most people none of this private information will ever surface. But, if one day you rise to prominence and become a thorn in the side to powerful people then all of a sudden they can go back and find all of this private information on you and it will somehow be leaked, and your most private views or deviances suddenly are there for the whole world to see."

Everyone will know you had to ask your partner what was going on in the middle of a film. You will be ruined.

Tony, meanwhile, is more worried about supposed Google, posting: "Google can track your activities across 80% of websites, and it ONLY makes money from using your information to sell advertisers better placed adverts. Worry about that."

Which didn't worry commenter Karts, who must be a tech industry stooge, who replied: "What terrible thing do you envisage happening because of that? Targeted adverts? Oh no, I might get adverts for things I might actually want!"

There's no such thing as a nice advert. They'll end up driving us away from all technology - in fact, just look at how unwelcoming ad-packed mobile games are these days.

Wrap modem in foil

Over on The Register, talk turned to how you might block such activities in a future world in which the internet of things is real and not just a marketing term to help sell 4G contacts.

Reader Anonymous Coward asked: "The key is if all of this data collection can be opt-in/out. Will there ever come a time when it's illegal or impossible for me to block the connections to the Net? Heaven forbid that they ever use safety as an excuse to mandate the use of IoT data collection. For example smart smoke alarms or cooking appliances that notify when there is a fire."

He's well up for a bit of surveillance conspiracy too, outlining this nightmare scenario: "Imagine a TV in a conference room that leaks juicy corporate secrets.. Or mistrials from breach of attorney / client privilege... Or just imagine all the juicy titbits that could be gleaned from TV Tapping the homes of executives, politicians, diplomats, journalists and whistleblowers etc..."

Except it's probably not actually happening. At least not yet.

Press red to hate

The Independent's coverage went down the predictable 1984 route, comparing the possible listening TV to the vision of George Orwell's privacy-banning future.

Reader Timestar is this week's voice of reason, asking: "To an extent this article misses the point. What about the hundreds of CCTV cameras in towns, cities across the world? Every time you use your credit/debit/loyalty card? And so on and so on..."

Yeah but that doesn't affect our EastEnders viewing time, Timestar.

Reader CXXL hopes this might be the latest infraction that finally gets the public interested in security issues, saying: "You either become some shut in survivalist or you learn about what is going on and carry on living your life with such knowledge and try to pass on the information to those who don't know and rally round to support privacy rights."

While Squidapedoyt is actually quite impressed by the bravado in such mass surveillance, saying: "If there had been a proposal that everyone should be compelled to carry a device which constantly reported their position to the authorities, there would have been howls of outrage. But as it is, we have not only consented to do so, we pay for the privilege."

And will continue to do so, especially when they make one that's a bit thinner.

TOPICS
Latest in Televisions
Sony Bravia 9 backlight demo showing images on screen and on raw backlight
TCL overtaking LG's premium TV sales is the inevitable result of OLED's biggest problem and mini-LED's biggest strength
Next-Gen Google TV
Google TV's Gemini Live support and other updates seemingly confirmed by new user survey – here's what to expect
Hisense U8N showing colorful landscape
I test TVs for a living, and these 4 TVs are the best for bright rooms and beating reflections
An array of Genelec speakers with. a Samsung soundbar in the middle at the Samsung Audio Lab
‘Atmos content costs too much money’: Samsung told me why Dolby Atmos isn't the future of surround sound, and why it launched Eclipsa Audio
Samsung S90C in front of gray background displaying pink demonstration image
Infuriating pop-up appearing on your Samsung TV? You're not alone – but there may be a fix
The Alpha 9 processor in an LG TV
This is the most important part of your new 4K TV if you're buying on a budget like me – and it's not the pixels
Latest in News
OnePlus Watch 3
Good news for OnePlus fans as it confirms the OnePlus Watch 3 will get three years of updates, not two
A laptop with a red screen with a white skull on it with the message: "RANSOMWARE. All your files are encrypted."
Major ransomware attack sees Tata Technologies hit - 1.4TB dataset with over 730,000 files allegedly stolen
Portrait of African-American teenage boy studying at home or in college dorm and using laptop, copy space
Windows 11’s Notepad gets AI-powered ‘Rewrite’ feature, but not everyone’s going to be happy about it
Pac-Man x PowerA promotional image.
Special edition Pac-Man Nintendo Switch and Xbox accessories from PowerA are on the way
Close up of PS5 DualSense controller leaning on a PS5
Sony goes full Xbox Insider with new Beta Program at PlayStation initiative, offering the testing of new games and features before release
Google Pixel Watch 3
Google rolls out major Pixel Watch upgrade for all users – here's what's new in Wear OS 5.1