Technology is exactly as evil as humanity

Darth Vader - also both good and evil.
Darth Vader - also both good and evil.

When we were mulling over what we could do on top of a plethora of Star Wars content to celebrate the film, it occurred to us that it might be fun to rebrand as techvadar for a couple of weeks, and for our stable-mates T3 to become T-3PO.

Obviously the next idea was that we would represent the Dark side and T3 the Light side – and we could each cover a different facet of technology.

But here's the rub: technology is definitely evil, and definitely a force for good – because technology is just a tool for humanity and therefore reflects both good evil and everything in between.

Here, Editor-in-Chief Patrick Goss explains why we need to stop wasting time anthropomorphising tech as evil.

Technology is an easy thing to blame for the world's wrongs – the PS4 becoming a terrorist communications system (hotly denied by Sony of course), flight sims training the evil-doers who took the Twin Towers down, unmanned drones bombing hospitals and computer games corrupting our youth.

There's a natural reaction as people get older to start seeing change as the true enemy – we have an innate fear of anything different or peculiar, and our tolerance for learning new things invariably lessens as we age.

Given that technology, by its very nature, is a constant march of change, demonising it is neither unexpected nor unusual.

And, of course, it has ever been thus: the printing press was seen as the root of all evil when it began to bring carefully hoarded knowledge to the masses, radio was expected to destroy communities, and the sheer scale of the connected world is daunting to anyone.

The reality is that technology, from the splitting of the atom to the invention of the internet, is merely a platform for all of humanity, a microcosm of us – and it therefore encompasses all that is great and good, and all that is insidious and bad about people.

When things go wrong, it is easier to blame a games console than to rail against the intangible decision process taken by someone who feels it's okay to take lives in the name of their religion.

And when anyone with a brain (and without the need to generate a headline) actually takes a second to think about it, the decision to blame our tools is ludicrous – like a monkey blaming its stick for failing to supply it with termites.

Most people know that Alfred Nobel, who gave his name to our most famous prize for peace, also invented dynamite, which has been responsible for countless deaths.

Many can quote Oppenheimer ("I am become death, the destroyer of worlds.") when he watched the first atomic bomb and recalled the words from the Bhagavad Gita.

There are millions who feel Edward Snowden should be prosecuted for giving away state secrets after blowing the whistle on the staggering level of governmental snooping into data we thought was private.

Humanity has never operated outside of the moral grey, and yet we often see the world in stark black and white – often while we ourselves feel entirely conflicted about what actually constitutes black and what constitutes white.

There are no shortage of moral debates around technology that sit firmly in this moral grey area, often revolving around the control of technology, from gun control to the extent of what a government should be able to do in the interests of security, but understanding that technology itself is not evil is a good starting point to cutting out something truly pointless.

Humanity is bad, not technology. Humanity is also good, not technology. The sooner we get this hammered into our brains the better.

TOPICS
Patrick Goss

Patrick Goss is the ex-Editor in Chief of TechRadar. Patrick was a passionate and experienced journalist, and he has been lucky enough to work on some of the finest online properties on the planet, building audiences everywhere and establishing himself at the forefront of digital content.  After a long stint as the boss at TechRadar, Patrick has now moved on to a role with Apple, where he is the Managing Editor for the App Store in the UK.

Latest in Entertainment
Tottenham Hotspur player Lucas Bergvall participates in the match at the AFAS Stadium for the UEFA Europa League
Tottenham vs AZ live stream: How to watch the Europa League online from anywhere
A close up of Captain America with Thor and Hulk in the background during the Assemble scene in Avengers: Endgame
'We will draw inspiration': Joe and Anthony Russo reveal which of Marvel's Secret Wars comic book series have influenced Avengers 5 and 6's plot
Indy the Dog sitting in front of the TV
South by Southwest has given me 4 new horror movies to look forward to, including one from a dog's perspective
Paul Rudd on the ground looking up at a unicorn, whose legs are visible
I've added 5 new movies and TV shows to my watchlist after they premiered at South by Southwest 2025
Cheltenham racing festival 2024 day four: Paul Townend on Galopin Des Champs crosses the finishing line for victory in the Gold Cup
Cheltenham Festival 2025 live stream: How to watch world-class horse racing online
Vinicius Junior of Real Madrid in action during the UEFA Champions League in March 2025
Atletico Madrid vs Real Madrid live stream: How to watch Champions League online
Latest in News
Man having Windows 11 problems with his laptop
Fed up of adverts creeping into Windows 11? You won’t like Microsoft’s latest update, then, although it does provide some important bug fixes
Apple Siri
Update your Apple device now: iOS 18.3.2 fixes a flaw that could be exploited by hackers
Google Chromecast 2
Chromecasts are still broken – but Google tells fuming owners not to factory reset their devices
ChatGPT
ChatGPT wants to write your next novel, and readers and writers alike should be very worried
Garmin Instinct 3 next to the Apple Watch Ultra 2
New figures claim the smartwatch market just shrunk for the first time ever, and the Apple Watch Ultra 3 is to blame
Hitman: World of Assassination on PSVR 2.
Hitman: World of Assassination hits PSVR 2 soon, finally giving you a reason to dust off your headset