I tried Apple's new iPhone comparison tool, but it didn't convince me to upgrade

Two Apple iPhones standing next to each other on an orange background
(Image credit: Apple)

Smartphone sales have been on the slide in recent years, because they've simply become too good. Why upgrade your iPhone when it still feels perfectly functional, and there are refurbished bargains to be had? Well, Apple's still hoping to convince you to upgrade with its new iPhone comparison tool – though the omission of one crucial detail means I'm still sticking with my iPhone 11 Pro (for now).

Apple's new 'Reasons to upgrade' tool, spotted by 9to5Mac, is actually a pretty useful summary of the real-world differences between the iPhone 15 series and models going back to the iPhone 11. Rather than a sheet of specs, Apple's tool visually spells out differences like camera resolution, storage differences and software features like Cinematic mode.

Clearly, it's a promotional tool, so neglects to mention some of the downsides of upgrading – like the fact that the Apple Trade-In value of my iPhone 11 Pro is likely around $70 (about £55 / AU$105). Also, it's a little galling to see USB-C touted as a reason to upgrade when Apple only belatedly added the feature on the iPhone 15 series after being strong-armed by the EU.

A close-up photo of a dog's eye taken on an iPhone

(Image credit: Apple)

But the tool's visual examples are also way more useful than a spec sheet, particularly when it comes to the camera differences. For example, when comparing the iPhone 11 Pro to the iPhone 15 Pro (a move I have been considering), you get an example of the cropping potential of the latter's 48MP sensor and a side-by-side of the stabilizing improvements delivered by Action mode for video. 

On the other hand, the tool would have more potential if it let you choose the areas you want to see compared. For example, it'd be useful to see the clear size differences between models or real-world examples of battery life. Also, one detail Apple naturally neglects to mention is that it launches new iPhones every September – which means "waiting six months could be your best bet" isn't part of the guidance. 

Why I'm waiting

Two videos of a woman running to show the iPhone's action mode

(Image credit: Apple)

Despite owning a positively ancient iPhone 11 Pro, I decided to skip on the iPhone 15 Pro Max this year because I'm a photographer – and my ideal Apple smartphone is likely to be this year's iPhone 16 Pro.

As the comparison tool tells me, upgrading to an iPhone 15 Pro Max now would give me Apple's 5x telephoto camera. But I'd also have to get a 6.7-inch phone, which is just a bit too big for my liking – if the rumors are true, the iPhone 16 Pro could offer that same camera in a phone with a more manageable 6.3-inch screen.

Also, because the iPhone 15 Pro Max debuted Apple's first 5x optical zoom, my feeling was that it could do with another year of software and hardware refinement before I'd take the leap. The 15 Pro Max is certainly still a great camera phone, which is why it won our Phone of the year award last year, but I always prefer to wait for the second-gen versions of new features.

The added twist this year are the growing rumors that iOS 18 is going to be the iPhone's biggest software upgrade yet. This is expected to be largely due to some AI features across the likes of Siri, Messages and more – and while Apple doesn't often restrict software features to newer models, I like the future-proofing potential of owning an iPhone that's been announced with those new features in mind. This tallies with new rumors that the iPhone 16 Pro's chipset could be designed with AI mind.

So while Apple's new iPhone comparison tool has its uses – unless you're looking at the iPhone 13 series, which is strangely omitted – I won't be clicking Apple's 'buy' button until later this year.

You might also like

Mark Wilson
Senior news editor

Mark is TechRadar's Senior news editor. Having worked in tech journalism for a ludicrous 17 years, Mark is now attempting to break the world record for the number of camera bags hoarded by one person. He was previously Cameras Editor at both TechRadar and Trusted Reviews, Acting editor on Stuff.tv, as well as Features editor and Reviews editor on Stuff magazine. As a freelancer, he's contributed to titles including The Sunday Times, FourFourTwo and Arena. And in a former life, he also won The Daily Telegraph's Young Sportswriter of the Year. But that was before he discovered the strange joys of getting up at 4am for a photo shoot in London's Square Mile. 

Read more
iPhone 16 Pro in hand
I'm a huge Apple fan but even I'm getting bored of the iPhone
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
I switched from an iPhone 12 Pro to an iPhone 16 Pro – here are 5 things I love and 3 disappointments
The iPhone 16 Pro cameras on a pink background
The best iPhone 2025: which Apple smartphone reigns supreme?
A silhouette with a question mark representing the Samsung Galaxy S25 next to an iPhone 16 on a split blue and orange background
Samsung Galaxy S25 vs iPhone 16: As rumors heat up, could Samsung best Apple this year?
Two iPhone 16 Pro phones on a grey background showing its camera and settings
I’m a photographer – 5 ways to take great photos on your iPhone 16 in 2025
iPhone 16e and iPhone 16 on orange background
iPhone 16e vs iPhone 16: which model is right for you?
Latest in iPhone
Two hands holding the Tecno Spark Slim phone
The world’s thinnest phone was just revealed, but a new iPhone 17 Air leak suggests it could be even slimmer
Apple iPhone 16e on blue background
This week's best Apple iPhone 16e deals: where to get the latest iPhone for cheap
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
Leaked iPhone 17 schematics show the Apple phones could be getting a speaker redesign
Apple iPhone 16e REVIEW
The iPhone 16e doesn’t have MagSafe, but apparently Apple thinks you didn’t want it anyway
Apple iPhone 16 Pro on purple background with price cut text overlay
Verizon's best iPhone 16 Pro deal is back - get a free phone, iPad, and Apple Watch without a trade
Apple iPhone 16 Pro REVIEW
The iPhone 17 Pro could come with 12GB of RAM to help it power though AI tasks
Latest in News
Apple iPad A16
Apple's new entry-level iPad ups the performance for the same price, but doesn't support Apple Intelligence
iPad Air M3
Apple updates iPad Air with powerful M3 chip and pairs it with Pro-level Magic Keyboard
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 6 in blue
The Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 7 might improve on its predecessor in one crucial way
Nvidia RTX 5070 Founders Edition GPU shown against a green and black backdrop
Nvidia RTX 5070 early pricing hints at plenty of GPUs at the MSRP – but I’ll believe it when I see it
US President Donald Trump speaks to the press as he signs an executive order to create a US sovereign wealth fund, in the Oval Office of the White House on February 3, 2025, in Washington, DC.
US set to pause cyber-offensive operations against Russia - but CISA says it won't stop
Guitar Hero Mobile
Activision shares first look at Guitar Hero Mobile and, yeah, it looks like AI slop