I find out which is best in the ultimate AI image generation head-to-head – Flux vs. Midjourney

Flux vs. Midjourney
(Image credit: Flux vs. Midjourney)

In the AI era, it seems that all we ever hear about is ChatGPT, and occasionally Gemini or Apple Intelligence will steal the limelight.

Beneath the headlines are hundreds of other, lesser-known AI tools that can help with all manner of tasks. Flux and Midjourney are two strong choices in the world of AI image generation, but which is best?

The tests

We curated a five-round test to compare the image-generation capabilities of these systems, showcasing what they can do well and what they’re not so suited to.

The prompts include a familiar fictional character doing an expected action; another expected action this time being performed by real humans; a slightly more obscure prompt with a standout adjective to steer the AI, an animal doing an unlikely action; and a broader prompt that gives the AI more freedom.


“Create an image of Jack Frost walking through the snow”

Flux vs. Midjourney

(Image credit: Craig Hale)

Nobody knows what Jack Frost looks like, yet he’s spoken about every year as the nights get shorter. We asked AI to produce an image of this fictional character befitting of the winter, and the results impress.

Although all five of the images produced fit the bill, we prefer Midjourney’s results because they include snow and wind, adding depth to an otherwise serene image.

Flux 9.21s
Midjourney 20.35s

Flux 0 - Midjourney 1

“Depict a team of footballers on the pitch”

Flux vs. Midjourney

(Image credit: Craig Hale)

Flux generated the most familiar image – a team of football players huddled on the pitch with an audience of spectators watching on. There’s something not quite right about this image though – wrongly positioned feet and the proximity of the players detracts from the image.

Midjourney created four slightly better images, but they’re all in a similar painted style, lacking any clear definition.

Flux 10.61s
Midjourney 20.02s

Flux 0 - Midjourney 1

“Create a chaotic illustration of a doggy day care centre”

Flux vs. Midjourney

(Image credit: Craig Hale)

Flux’s content seems fine on the surface, but look a little closer and you’ll spot the headless dog in the puddle or the three-legged, cross-boddied lion-like dog to its right. Other anomalies make the output disappointing, but the apparent cat to the left of the puddle would certainly add to the chaotic feeling.

Maybe Midjourney’s illustration of chaos is better – the four images show dogs everywhere, and are much closer to what we’d imagined when setting out the prompt.

Flux 10.96s
Midjourney 19.50s

Flux 0 - Midjourney 1

“Make a lifelike image of a cheetah playing hockey”

Flux vs. Midjourney

(Image credit: Craig Hale)

Flux’s attempt at a cheetah playing hockey, albeit ice hockey, is admirable, and the fact that it’s standing on its hind legs like a human adds to the fun.

However, the cheetahs produced by Midjourney are much more accurate, leading to better overall results. The fourth cheetah doesn’t seem to be holding the hockey stick in quite the right place, but we can overlook that for the quality of the first three outputs.

Flux 11.05s
Midjourney 20.27s

Flux 0 - Midjourney 1

“Show me what it's like to live with the dinosaurs”

Flux vs. Midjourney

(Image credit: Craig Hale)

We already tried this test in another comparison between two AI image generators, but we weren’t too impressed with the results so hoped for a better show this time around.

The detail in Flux’s images is exceptional, however it missed the mark when showing us what it would be like for a human to live with the dinosaur in question.

Midjourney nailed the task, showing humans and dinosaurs interacting in a variety of settings. It didn’t take too much longer to generate the output, either. We think 20 seconds is a reasonable time to wait for such a solid effort.

Flux 13.00s
Midjourney 20.23

Flux 0 - Midjourney 1

Midjourney vs. Flux: Which is best?

Flux 0 - Midjourney 5

Unfortunately, Flux ended the head-to-head with zero points in the bag, but that doesn’t instantly rule it out as a worthy AI image generator. The truth is that Midjourney just outperformed Flux across all five rounds, but Flux was still able to product good images. Some just missed the mark and didn’t quite respond to our prompts.

On the flip side, Midjourney was consistently impressive and offered a good range of images to pick from. Generating four completely separate images adds to its appeal, but it’s strictly an image generator, whereas Flux does offer some other artificial intelligence tools too, like a video generator and more, making it a good pick for social media marketers.

Craig Hale

With several years’ experience freelancing in tech and automotive circles, Craig’s specific interests lie in technology that is designed to better our lives, including AI and ML, productivity aids, and smart fitness. He is also passionate about cars and the decarbonisation of personal transportation. As an avid bargain-hunter, you can be sure that any deal Craig finds is top value!

Read more
Flux vs. Stable Diffusion
I play out Flux vs. Stable Diffusion in a heated five-round test to determine the best AI image generator
Midjourney vs. Stable Diffusion
Midjourney vs. Stable Diffusion – which AI creates the best images? We find out
Dall-E vs. Midjourney
The ultimate battle – Dall-E vs. Midjourney: which is the best AI image generator? We find out
Leonardo vs. Midjourney
Leonardo vs. Midjourney – I put these AI image generators to the test to find out which is best
Midjourney during our review process
What is Midjourney: everything you need to know about the AI image generator
Stable Video Diffusion demos
What is Stable Diffusion: everything you need to know about the AI image generator
Latest in Pro
China
Chinese hackers who targeted key US infrastructure charged by Justice Department
Concept art representing cybersecurity principles
What businesses need for modern third-party risk management
linkedin
Watch out - that LinkedIn email could be a fake, laden with malware
An American flag flying outside the US Capitol building against a blue sky
Mass federal layoffs will have “devastating impact on cybersecurity, former NSA cybersecurity director warns
A hand reaching out to touch a futuristic rendering of an AI processor.
North Korean fake job hackers are going the extra mile to make sure their scams seem legit
Half man, half AI.
How finance teams can avoid falling behind in the AI race
Latest in Versus
Panasonic Lumix S1R II alongside Panasonic Lumix S5 II on a split green / orange background
Panasonic Lumix S1R II vs Lumix S5 II: time to upgrade?
Logitech Z407 and Creative Pebble Plus desktop speakers against a TechRadar background
Logitech Z407 vs Creative Pebble Plus: Neither of these budget speakers sound cheap, but which go best with your setup?
Two gaming monitors, Gigabyte M32UC on the left side vs the Corsair Xeneon 32UHD144 on the right against a TechRadar background
Gigabyte M32UC vs Corsair Xeneon 32UHD144: Which 4K display is right for you?
iPhone 16e and iPhone 16 on orange background
iPhone 16e vs iPhone 16: which model is right for you?
Windows 11 Start menu layout choices: Grid view
Windows 11 vs Linux for business: which operating system should you embrace?
A phone sitting on a laptop keyboard with the Microsoft Outlook logo on the screen.
Gmail vs Outlook for business: which email system is right for your organization?