Seagate Momentus XT 500GB review

A mutant hard drive born of SSD toxic waste

Seagate Momentus XT 500GB
Hybrid HDD/SSD done right

TechRadar Verdict

Seagate proves that hybrid has a future. The Momentous XT is a top performer without the price premium.

Pros

  • +

    Value for money

  • +

    Almost desktop drive performance

Cons

  • -

    No write acceleration

  • -

    Power use same as traditional drive

Why you can trust TechRadar We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about how we test.

Seagate's magniloquently monikered Momentous XT has finally arrived in the TechRadar lab, sporting both traditional spinning platters and a chunk of flash memory, resurrecting a concept we'd long dismissed as vapourware.

It's the first hybrid drive we've seen for years: a statement which will make younger readers ask, what's a hybrid drive?

Back before solid state drives became the preferred option for every laptop from the ASUS EeePC to the Alienware M11x, hybrid storage was the Next Big Thing that everyone was excited about.

Drives made entirely of flash memory, like the Kingston V+ series, had been conceived and generally approved of, but everyone assumed they'd be too expensive to be of any practical use for quite some time to come.

While we waited for NAND flash prices to come down, so the theory went, hybrid drives like the Seagate Momentous XT would help sate demand for more performance. Hybrids have both spinning platters for large amounts of cheap storage, and a chunk of solid state memory for speedy access and a performance boost.

Theoretically, they are the best of both worlds, with all the advatanges of both SSDs and traditional disks.

But their time never came.

Before a decent hybrid ever went on sale, solid state prices crashed and the public decided that they didn't really care about the performance difference between traditional and SSD storage anyway.

Or did they?

TOPICS
Latest in Pro
Application Security Testing Concept with Digital Magnifying Glass Scanning Applications to Detect Vulnerabilities - AST - Process of Making Apps Resistant to Security Threats - 3D Illustration
Google bug bounty payments hit nearly $12 million in 2024
Ai tech, businessman show virtual graphic Global Internet connect Chatgpt Chat with AI, Artificial Intelligence.
How decision makers can overcome analysis paralysis with AI
Representational image of a cybercriminal
Criminals are spreading malware disguised as DeepSeek AI
Europe
Apple and Meta set to face fines for alleged breaches of EU DMA
An AI face in profile against a digital background.
Unlocking AI’s Transformative Potential for Competitive Edge
AMD logo
Security flaw means AMD Zen CPUs can be "jailbroken"
Latest in Reviews
An AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D on its retail packaging
I've reviewed three generations of 3D V-cache processors, and the AMD Ryzen 9 9950X3D is the best there is
Mac Studio on a desk
Apple Mac Studio (M3 Ultra): the ultimate creative workstation
Apple iPad Air 11-inch M3 (2025) Review
I tested the 11-inch iPad Air with M3 for five days, and it stretches the value even further with more power for the same price
Cricut Maker 4 cutting machine making projects with basswood and cardstock
After a month with Cricut Maker 4 I’ve pushed my crafting past its limit, and past the limit of the machine
Apple MacBook Air 13-inch (M4) REVIEW
The Apple MacBook Air 13-inch (M4) is the best ultraportable – and the new price makes it even more appealing
HP Series 7 Pro 727pm during our review
I tested the HP Series 7 Pro 727pm business monitor and it may not be cheap, but it's still an extraordinary 4K productivity panel