Heretic is a new horror hit but even eerie Hugh Grant couldn't make it my favorite A24 movie of the year

Hugh Grant with a lit candle in front of him
(Image credit: A24)

When the first trailer for Heretic was released, it immediately went into my new A24 movies I can’t wait to watch in 2024 list. It's easy to see why, and the trailers for the new movie were very intriguing indeed. Namely, everyone was talking about how it was nice to see Hugh Grant moving from his romantic comedy roots into something far more sinister.

The set-up for Heretic is simple yet effective: Two young Mormon missionaries show up to the house of Mr Reed, who has apparently requested a visit to learn more about their faith. Unfortunately for them, they've walked into a horrifying trap that could cost them their sanity or even their lives. But despite the great concept and the fact it did turn out to be a very good movie, there's another recent 2024 release that holds a special place in my heart. A movie that deserves its spot on our best Max movies list, that's for sure.

Why I Saw the TV Glow remains my favorite movie of the year

Two teenagers sit on a couch with a fish tank in the background

(Image credit: Max / WBD)

This is by no means me pitting movies against the other needlessly, but more of a celebration of why I Saw The TV Glow has had such an impact on me. It's not a particularly unique take but I can count on one hand the amount of A24 movies I disliked, and it's refreshing to see their output continuing to be as strong as it is.

For me, I Saw The TV Glow is perhaps A24's greatest achievement to date. I love everything about it from the colour palette, the way it plays on fun cheesy 90s TV, the exploration of fandom and identity, everything about it is wonderful and I found myself completely transfixed. I'm not alone either, as my colleague Rowan Davies also thanked the movie for encouraging him to revisit his favorite Hulu show. Its impact simply cannot be ignored, it's as terrifying as it is beautiful, it manages to mix both of these feelings into something really special.

I was curious whether or not anything would manage to knock this movie off my top spot, especially during the Halloween season. Even The Substance, which recently got a streaming release date, wasn't enough to do it. I consider that to be the best body horror of the year though, it's definitely earned that title! It's been a strong year for horrors and yet Jane Schoenbrun's brilliant movie has stayed firmly at my number one spot. Honestly, I'm impressed.

Is Heretic still worth watching?

Yes! Don't get me wrong, I loved it. It scared me more than I expected it to, to the point where I did find myself jumping out of my skin at one moment in particular, so it's a strong contender for the best horror movies of the year in my opinion. It's just not the best.

A lot of it is riding on Hugh Grant's performance and I can confirm he does serious bad guy very well. Sure, we've seen him in more comedic villain roles like Paddington 2 and the Dungeons and Dragons movie, but I loved his venture into horror and I hope he does more like it. His character is this weird combination of obnoxious, charming and utterly frightening, to the point where you feel very uncomfortable watching him. Discomfort is definitely what Heretic is going for and it does it very well, forcing you to ask questions along the way.

The best part about this is I'm actually recommending you watch both movies (I Saw The TV Glow is currently on Max), and I for one am thrilled we're being treated to so many good, thought provoking horrors. Long may it continue.

You might also like

Lucy Buglass
Senior Entertainment Writer

Lucy is a long-time movie and television lover who is an approved critic on Rotten Tomatoes. She has written several reviews in her time, starting with a small self-ran blog called Lucy Goes to Hollywood before moving onto bigger websites such as What's on TV and What to Watch, with TechRadar being her most recent venture. Her interests primarily lie within horror and thriller, loving nothing more than a chilling story that keeps her thinking moments after the credits have rolled. Many of these creepy tales can be found on the streaming services she covers regularly.

When she’s not scaring herself half to death with the various shows and movies she watches, she likes to unwind by playing video games on Easy Mode and has no shame in admitting she’s terrible at them. She also quotes The Simpsons religiously and has a Blinky the Fish tattoo, solidifying her position as a complete nerd. 

Read more
The cast of The Parenting
The Parenting is Max's #1 most-watched movie but it has frightening reviews – here are 3 better horror films with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes
Hereditary
5 new horror movies on Netflix, Shudder, Max and more in January 2025
A close up of Hugh Grant's Mister Reed in Heretic
7 new horror movies on Netflix, Shudder, Max and more in March 2025
Cillian Murphy as a zombie in 28 Years Later
The 6 biggest horror movies coming in 2025 that I can't wait to watch
Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy in The Gorge
5 new horror movies to stream on Netflix, Shudder, Max and more in February 2025
Jeremy Renner dressed as a police officer in The Town
5 new Hulu movies with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes that I can't wait to watch in January 2025
Latest in Entertainment
Buzz Lightyear Space Ranger Spin Rennovations
Disney’s giving a classic Buzz Lightyear ride a tech overhaul – here's everything you need to know
Robert Downey Jr reveals himself as Doctor Doom to a delighted crowd at San Diego Comic-Con 2024
Marvel has revealed the full, 27-strong cast for Avengers: Doomsday, and there are plenty of heroes who seemingly won't be part of its roster
A collage of Elizabeth Olsen's Scarlet Witch and Tatiana Maslany's She-Hulk
Marvel fans are already tired of Doomsday and Secret Wars cast gossip as two more superheroes get linked with roles in the next two Avengers movies
Venezuela's forward #09 Jhonder Cadiz celebrates after scoring during the 2026 FIFA World Cup South American qualifiers football match between Ecuador and Venezuela, at the Rodrigo Paz Delgado stadium in Quito, on March 21, 2025 ahead of Venezuela vs Peru
Venezuela vs Peru live stream: how to watch today's FIFA World Cup 2026 qualifier anywhere online
The cast of Alone Australia season 3, standing in a knee-high body of water
How to watch Alone Australia season 3 online – stream the survival show from anywhere
This City Is Ours
How to watch This City Is Ours online – stream Sean Bean crime drama from anywhere
Latest in Features
Google Gemini 2.5 and ChatGPT o3-mini
I pitted Gemini 2.5 Pro against ChatGPT o3-mini to find out which AI reasoning model is best
The cast of The Residence peek from a doorway
Netflix's #2 most-watched show is the new madcap whodunnit The Residence –here are 3 more mysteries to stream next
Google AI Mode
I tried Google's new AI mode powered by Gemini, and it might be the end of Search as we know it
Saily eSIM by Nord Security
"Much more than just an eSIM service" - I spoke to the CEO of Saily about the future of travel and its impact on secure eSIM technology
A collage image showing images from the TV shows The White Lotus on Max, Black Mirror on Netflix and The Handmaid's Tale on Hulu.
I'm pausing my Prime Video, Apple TV+ and Paramount+ subscriptions in April 2025 – here are the 3 streaming services I'm keeping instead
Gemini on a smartphone.
Gemini is pulling ahead of ChatGPT – combining Deep Research with Audio Overviews is one of the best uses of AI I’ve seen so far