Euphoria creator’s canceled HBO show with 19% on Rotten Tomatoes scored an Emmy nod, so… believe in yourself, guys

The Idol
(Image credit: HBO.com)

Sam Levinson's controversial HBO drama series The Idol has received a 2024 Emmy nomination for Outstanding Choreography for Scripted Programming, despite its low 19% Rotten Tomatoes score.

The nomination is in reference to Nina McNeely's choreography for the show's rehearsal music video shoot, which is led by troubled pop star Jocelyn (Lily-Rose Depp) and her backup dancers, including Blackpink's Jennie Kim.

The Idol caused a scandal at the Cannes Film Festival and continued to stir up controversy when it debuted on one of the best streaming services in June 2023 with its overtly sexual and violent scenes. HBO ultimately decided to cancel the show after one season, with a spokesperson telling Popsugar at the time: “The Idol was one of HBO’s most provocative original programs, and we’re pleased by the strong audience response. After much thought and consideration, HBO, as well as the creators and producers, have decided not to move forward with a second season. We’re grateful to the creators, cast and crew for their incredible work.”

Levinson is known to push boundaries in his projects, most notably in his hard-hitting teen drama series Euphoria, which won nine Emmy Awards and became a huge cultural phenomenon. But whether Levinson's efforts with The Idol will earn him another Emmy win remains to be seen on September 15.

The Idol | Official Trailer | HBO - YouTube The Idol | Official Trailer | HBO - YouTube
Watch On

What is The Idol about?

Co-created by Levinson, Abel Tesfaye – AKA The Weeknd – and Reza Fahim, The Idol follows pop idol Jocelyn (Depp) who resolves to become the greatest star in the USA after having a nervous breakdown. She then starts a complex relationship with Tedros (The Weeknd), a sleazy night club owner and cult leader who offers larger ambitions for Jocelyn's career.

The Idol also stars Rachel Sennott (Bottoms), Dan Levy (Schitt's Creek), Da’Vine Joy Randolph (The Holdovers), Hank Azaria (The Simpsons), Troye Sivan (Trolls Band Together), Moses Sumney (MaXXXine), Hari Nef (Barbie) and Suzanna Son (Red Rocket).

The drama will be facing tough competition in the scripted series category, with Only Murders in the Building choreographer John Carrafa, Palm Royale choreographer Brooke Lipton and Physical choreographer Jennifer Hamilton all up for the Emmy Award for Outstanding Choreography for Scripted Programming.

Speaking about the nomination, The Idol choreographer McNeely said in a statement: “I’m beyond honored and grateful for this nomination. Thank you to Sam, Abel, Lily and everyone involved for their trust and the opportunity to work on such a special project.”

You might also like

Grace Morris
Entertainment Writer

After graduating with a degree in Writing and Film Studies, Grace dived into the world of entertainment where she started writing all about the must-watch shows and movies at What To Watch. Now Grace is on her next writing adventure at TechRadar, where she uses her expertise to help readers keep up to date on the biggest TV shows and movies in the ever-changing world of streaming. If she’s not writing about her passion for entertainment, you’ll find her watching reality shows while feasting on chocolate. 

Read more
Zoe Saldana and Karla Sofia Gascon in Netflix's Emilia Perez
I can’t understand Emilia Pérez’s record-breaking Oscar nominee success – I’d rather put myself through Joker 2 again
Bookie
Max just canceled a comedy show with 90% on Rotten Tomatoes from a huge name – and fans of Bookie are not happy
Rick and Chelsea stand together in The White Lotus season 3
The White Lotus season 3 is Max's #1 show – here are 3 more comedy dramas that are just as good with over 95% on Rotten Tomatoes
Zeus looks unimpressed as he leans on a table in Netflix's Kaos TV show
9 canceled Netflix shows in 2024 that you should still watch
A close up of Oz Cobb sitting at a table with a glass of whiskey in The Penguin
The 2025 Golden Globes has kicked off awards season - here are 5 wins that surprised me the most
Ralph Fiennes as Cardinal Thomas Lawrence in Conclave
The 2025 BAFTA nominees have been revealed, and Conclave is the big winner – but one of my favorite movies got nothing, and it's a crime
Latest in HBO Max
Y2K cast looking shocked
Y2K has a streaming release date on Max, so you can witness the technology uprising at home
A collage of Ellie and Joel in The Last of Us season 2
The Last of Us season 2's new trailer teases a huge showdown between Bella Ramsey's Ellie and Pedro Pascal's Joel, but the big moment I'm waiting for is still being held back
ER doctors, including Dr. Michael "Robby" Rabinavitch (Noah Wyle) attend to a patient in The Pitt
Max's #2 show The Pitt has left viewers breathless – here are 3 more medical dramas with over 85% on Rotten Tomatoes to get your heart pounding
A piece of paper with the words 'an HBO Original film' on it next to a pile of snow
Jesse Armstrong’s next HBO Original sounds like another Succession-style satire starring Steve Carrell and Jason Schwartzman
Divine G looking at his fellow theater group performers in Sing Sing
6 Max movies and shows I’m most excited to watch in March, from A24 horrors to an offbeat Adult Swim animation
Anthony Mackie as Will in Elevation.
Elevation is Max's #1 movie - here are 3 more sci-fi thrillers with over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes to watch next
Latest in News
Garmin Instinct 3 in Neotropic Green
"I'm an idiot": Garmin user reveals how fixing one setting completely changed their training after months of making no progress
The main battle pass characters in Fortnite Lawless, including Midas, Sub Zero and a large wolf-man
You'll finally be able to play Fortnite on Windows 11 Arm-powered laptops as Epic Games partners with Qualcomm
DeepSeek on an iPhone
OpenAI calls on US government to ban DeepSeek, calling it ‘state-subsidized’ and ‘state-controlled’
Abstract image of cyber security in action.
MassJacker malware targets those looking for pirated software
Stress
Complexity of IT systems could be increasing security risks for businesses
Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 3
Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 3 enters development as team promises to support Space Marine 2 'with exciting content and regular updates in the coming years'