I’m still angry at Netflix for canceling the most unpredictable mystery show I’ve seen – here’s why The Society is still worth streaming

Allie looks into the camera with a serious expression as Will stands behind her in The Society.
The Society was canceled after one season. (Image credit: Seacia Pavao/Netflix)

Sorry Netflix, but I haven't forgiven you for canceling one of the best drama shows The Society. Yes, I know it's been years now, but with the amount of cancelations the best streaming service has recently done, it's a hurtful reminder of the beloved shows that were cut short by the Netflix ax.

The harsh memory of The Society's cancelation was brought back to the front of my mind while writing about Netflix quietly canceling the most realistic zombie show I’ve ever seen Black Summer (sob!). Unfortunately, the streaming giant has scrapped over 15 shows this year so far, with dark comedy Greek mythology-inspired series Kaos being the most recent show to be controversially canceled.

The Society definitely deserves a space on my list of seven shows canceled by Netflix in 2024 so far that you should still watch, even though it was canceled four years ago – but I'm just not over it. And I'm not the only one either, with watchers creating a Change.org petition to renew The Society for a second season.

Following its debut in May 2019, the YA drama was renewed for a second season in July of the same year. Production was set to start in March 2020 for the new instalment, but Netflix decided to can The Society season 2 due to the Covid--19 pandemic.

This best Netflix show with 86% on Rotten Tomatoes isn't just your average teen drama with the formulaic tropes of teenage angst, high school gossip and best friend backstabbing. It's actually a thoughtful and realistic portrayal of community, politics and culture with a unique premise that had a lot of potential to become a huge success.

Why you should stream The Society

THE SOCIETY Official Trailer (2019) Kathryn Newton, Teen Netflix TV Series HD - YouTube THE SOCIETY Official Trailer (2019) Kathryn Newton, Teen Netflix TV Series HD - YouTube
Watch On

What would you do if there was a killer in your community? With no police or prison around, would you execute the criminal or lock them up and throw away the key? What if you're pregnant and there's no hospital staff or midwives to help you deliver your baby? These are the sorts of issues that arise in The Society.

Commonly described as a modern take on The Lord of the Flies, The Society follows a group of teenagers who return home from a school trip and realize all of the town's adults have mysteriously disappeared. In order to survive, they create their own society, which quickly descends into chaos and becomes a "survival of the fittest" with shocking deaths, betrayals, and secrets as the high school students rebel against the rules.

While the intense plot, unpredictable twists, and unraveling mystery will keep you intrigued throughout the 10-episode series, it's also the complex and authentic characters that make The Society a must watch. There's an eclectic mix of teenagers you meet - some you love and some you hate. From a manipulative psychopath to a devout Catholic, they all have their own stories to tell and deal with their issues in various ways.

The Society also raises awareness on important social issues such as teen pregnancy, domestic abuse, mental health, and living with a disability that makes this fantastical story all the more true to life and engrossing.

The New Ham teenagers gather around at the church in The Society.

(Image credit: Seacia Pavao/Netflix)

Hopes of The Society season 2 was struck down with even more bad luck when the show creator revealed to Variety that he and his creative partners nearly released a graphic novel that would have revealed season 2's storylines, but the publisher went out of business.

However, he did add that the writing crew are working out how to continue the story in a new way. He said: "I have consistent conversations with a bunch of the writers and Marc Webb about how we might bring this back in some way. We don’t have an answer yet, and I wouldn’t count on it, but I don’t do that with every show that gets canceled."

"The audience still wants to talk about it. They are still moved by it and want answers to the questions and then new questions are posed. I just don’t know whether the world is going to work in a way that aligns for us, but we’ll keep trying for a while because it’s gotten under my skin as well." Fingers crossed this happens!

Now that The Society has been canceled before season 2, I won't ever get the answers to the series biggest mysteries – please Netflix, I need to know where the adults went and who the mystery father of Becca's (Gideon Adlon) baby is. Despite this, The Society is definitely still worth the watch, and deserves as much praise as it gets.

You might also like

Grace Morris
Entertainment Writer

After graduating with a degree in Writing and Film Studies, Grace dived into the world of entertainment where she started writing all about the must-watch shows and movies at What To Watch. Now Grace is on her next writing adventure at TechRadar, where she uses her expertise to help readers keep up to date on the biggest TV shows and movies in the ever-changing world of streaming. If she’s not writing about her passion for entertainment, you’ll find her watching reality shows while feasting on chocolate. 

Read more
Zeus looks unimpressed as he leans on a table in Netflix's Kaos TV show
9 canceled Netflix shows in 2024 that you should still watch
Dream sits in a chair in season 1 of Netflix's The Sandman TV show
I’m not surprised The Sandman is Netflix’s first canceled show of 2025 after Dead Boy Detectives was axed
Peter looks to the side with the city skyline behind him in The Night Agent season 2
3 Netflix shows I stopped watching and wouldn't go back to
Nicole Kidman wears a blue blouse with her arms crossed.
Netflix might be renewing The Perfect Couple and Beauty in Black for season 2, but I don’t get why when it’s canceled shows with poorer ratings
A still from Netflix's new miniseries Adolescence starring Stephen Graham
Adolescence is the TV show of the year – here’s why the Netflix crime drama had me gripped from start to finish
Kristen Bell and Adam Brody on a couch looking at each other with a laptop in front of them
Disney Plus had two of the most-streamed shows of 2024 – here are the 3 I recommend watching on Netflix, Hulu and Prime Video
Latest in Netflix
Wonka poster
Netflix cooks up sweet new reality TV series based on Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and it's a dream come true for me
Eddie Miller (Stephen Graham) looks as his anxious son Jamie (Owen Cooper) in a prison cell.
Netflix's #1 show Adolescence is one of the best crime dramas I've seen – here are 3 more with over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes
Adam Sandler as Happy Gilmore, swinging a golf club while a crowd watches
Netflix confirms Happy Gilmore's long-awaited comeback in new trailer, and I hope it won't be a swing and a miss
A still from Netflix's new miniseries Adolescence starring Stephen Graham
Adolescence is the TV show of the year – here’s why the Netflix crime drama had me gripped from start to finish
Sakata in Demon City holds a large cleaver-like weapon
Demon City on Netflix is Japan's answer to John Wick with a dash of Oldboy, and it rocks
Cristin Milioti in Black Mirror season 7
Netflix launches trailer for Black Mirror season 7, giving us a look at its first-ever sequel episode and an unexpected returning character
Latest in Opinion
Polar Pacer
Polar's latest software update might have finally convinced me to ditch my Garmin
An image of the Samsung Display concept games console
Forget the Nintendo Switch 2 – I want a foldable games console
Image of Naoe in AC Shadows
Assassin's Creed Shadows is hands-down one of the most beautiful PC ports I've ever seen
Apple CEO Tim Cook
Forget Siri, Apple needs to launch a folding iPhone and get back on track
construction
Building in the digital age: why construction’s future depends on scaling jobsite intelligence
Concept art representing cybersecurity principles
Navigating the rise of DeepSeek: balancing AI innovation and security