Missing You is Netflix's #1 show, but it's a 'miss' for me – here are 3 better mystery thrillers with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes

Rosalind Eleazar and Ashley Walters at a party in Missing You
(Image credit: Netflix)

Harlan Coben's latest mystery thriller Missing You has quickly taken the number one spot on Netflix's Top 10 TV shows this week with over 21 million views worldwide.

When detective Kat Donovan (Rosalind Eleazar) finds her "missing" fiancé on a dating app over a decade since his disappearance, this leads her to reopen the unsolved mystery surrounding her father's murder and see if there's a connection between the two.

During my interview with Missing You's creator Victoria Asare-Archer, she told me it's the most emotional Harlan Coben adaptation yet, but it seems the critics weren't so pleased with the series, giving it a 52% Rotten Tomatoes score. Meanwhile, the audience gave it just 28%.

Unfortunately, this doesn't go down as one of my favorite Harlan Coben series, let alone one of the best Netflix shows, so here are three mystery thrillers with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes to unravel next.

The Snow Girl

The Snow Girl | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube The Snow Girl | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On
  • RT score: 100%
  • Age rating: TV-MA
  • Length: ~45 minute episodes
  • Creators: Jesús Mesas and Javier Andrés Roig

Based on the novel by Javier Castillo, The Snow Girl (La chica de nieve) is a Spanish series that follows newspaper journalist Miren Rojo (Milena Smit) as she investigates the disappearance of missing girl Amaya Martín, who vanished during the 2010 Cavalcade of Magi in Málaga. The Snow Girl is one of six under-the-radar Netflix thrillers with 100% on Rotten Tomatoes that you have to try for its clever twists, skilful time jumps and captivating storytelling.

The Law According to Lidia Poët

The Law According to Lidia Poët | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube The Law According to Lidia Poët | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On
  • RT score: 100%
  • Age rating: TV-MA
  • Length: ~49 minute episodes
  • Creators: Guido Iuculano and Davide Orsini

The Law According to Lidia Poët is an Italian mystery thriller and period drama rolled into one. Set in late 1880s Italy, the series is loosely based on the life of Lidia Poët, Italy's first modern female lawyer. The plot charts Poët's (Matilda de Angelis) dogged pursuit of a law career after the court rules that her enrollment is illegal and disbars her. While preparing her appeal to overturn the court's decision, Poët investigates murders at her brother's law firm. Alongside the spectacular performances of the cast, the beguiling costumes and scenery make The Law According to Lidia Poët a true feast for the eyes.

Stay Close

Stay Close | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube Stay Close | Official Trailer | Netflix - YouTube
Watch On
  • RT Score: 92%
  • Age rating: TV-MA
  • Length: ~47 minute episodes
  • Creator: Harlan Coben

If you weren't a fan of Harlan Coben's latest twisty thriller Missing You, then there's plenty more to explore in Netflix's library, including Stay Close. In my opinion, Stay Close is one of Coben's best book-to-screen adaptations alongside Fool Me Once and The Stranger. Murder mysteries, missing people, and dark secrets are Coben's signature hooks and these are all used magnificently in this smart thriller. In Stay Close, the lives of a photojournalist, a suburban mom, and a homicide detective are thrown into chaos by an awful event from the past. What comes next us are edge-of-your-seat thrills and shocking twists.

You might also like

Grace Morris
Entertainment Writer

After graduating with a degree in Writing and Film Studies, Grace dived into the world of entertainment where she started writing all about the must-watch shows and movies at What To Watch. Now Grace is on her next writing adventure at TechRadar, where she uses her expertise to help readers keep up to date on the biggest TV shows and movies in the ever-changing world of streaming. If she’s not writing about her passion for entertainment, you’ll find her watching reality shows while feasting on chocolate. 

Read more
Rosalind Eleazar holds up a phone to her ear looking concerned
‘It feels a lot more intense’: Netflix’s Missing You creator says the show is the most emotional Harlan Coben adaptation yet
Helen Webb smiles at something off camera as she waves goodbye to Sam standing behind her in Black Doves.
Netflix’s #2 most-watched show Black Doves is the spy thriller I didn't know I needed – here are 3 more with over 92% on Rotten Tomatoes
Keanu Reeves as an animated character in Secret Level.
Secret Level is Prime Video’s new hit show, but it’s game over with the critics – here are 3 better anthology series to watch
Donald Glover and Francesca Sloane in Prime Video's Mr and Mrs Smith
Prime Video's On Call has been robbed of good reviews – here are 3 better crime dramas with over 85% on Rotten Tomatoes
Peter looks to the side with the city skyline behind him in The Night Agent season 2
The Night Agent reclaims Netflix’s #1 spot with season 2 – here are 3 of my favorite thrillers with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes that are just as good
Robert DeNiro in Zero Day wearing a US flag pin badge and a smart suit
Netflix's #2 show Zero Day has viewers divided - here are 3 better political thrillers with over 85% on Rotten Tomatoes to watch instead
Latest in Netflix
Peter looks to the side with the city skyline behind him in The Night Agent season 2
3 Netflix shows I stopped watching and wouldn't go back to
Owen Hendricks looks at something off camera in The Recruit season 2.
Netflix cancels spy thriller The Recruit, and I know which show to blame
Millie Bobby Brown's Michelle armed with a paint gun while standing next to some robots in Netflix's The Electric State movie
The Electric State could have been a great Netflix sci-fi movie, but it's just more evidence that it's Marvel or bust for the Russo brothers
Isla Gordon smiles with her arms on her hips as two basketball players stand behind her in Running Point.
Running Point is a Netflix slam dunk – here are 3 more sports comedy shows with over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes to enjoy next
Michelle, Keats, and Doctor Amherst looking unimpressed and worried in The Electric State
Netflix drops trailer for The Electric State, and I'm getting serious District 9 vibes
A still from Blade Runner
3 new movies on Netflix in March 2025 with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes
Latest in Features
Lady Gaga sat at a press conference table for Spotify's fan event
Spotify’s press conference with Lady Gaga shows that music streaming services really do think about the fans after all
Sterling K. Brown as Agent Xavier Collins in Paradise
I'm relieved that Paradise season 2 has been confirmed after that mind-blowing finale
Peter looks to the side with the city skyline behind him in The Night Agent season 2
3 Netflix shows I stopped watching and wouldn't go back to
SimCity BuildIt
I can’t remember a time when SimCity didn’t exist – now I’m hooked on the app version
The player attacks an enemy in Judgement.
The latest PlayStation sale is here, and these are the five games under $15 / £15 I've got in my basket
 In this photo illustration a Google Play logo seen displayed on a smartphone.
Why is there so much spyware hidden in the Play Store?