Mea Culpa is Netflix's #1 movie, but it's getting savaged – watch these 3 thrillers instead

A promo image of Mea Culpa
(Image credit: Netflix)

It's fair to say that the reviews of Mea Culpa, the new Netflix thriller, aren't being very kind. It's currently sitting with a Rotten Tomatoes rating of just 15%, and while that's only based on 13 reviews so far, it does appear that if this film were a bird, it'd be a turkey up there with the likes of Gigli.

The Guardian says it's "hilariously messy" – and not deliberately so – while the New York Times says that this "wilfully steamy" thriller is "decidedly silly". Variety tries to have it both ways, noting that "many will write it off as as shlock" but "there’s something admirable about a filmmaker who knows exactly what his audience wants." It doesn't sound like this will be threatening our list of the new Netflix movies, in any case.

Don't worry, though. If you want a thriller that'll keep you entertained reliably, there are plenty of decent options among the best Netflix movies. Here are three of our favorites.

LA Confidential

Based on the complex and pitch-dark James Ellroy novel, LA Confidential is set in the murky world of 1950s Los Angeles when the only thing scarier than the criminals is the cops. It follows three policemen who attempt to take on the corruption surrounding an unsolved murder, and as the late Roger Ebert wrote in his review it's a film noir but it's also so much more. "It contains all the elements of police action, but in a sharply clipped, more economical style; the action exists not for itself but to provide an arena for the personalities. The dialogue is lovely; not the semiparody of a lot of film noir, but the words of serious people trying to reveal or conceal themselves." It's an exceptional film.

Jackie Brown

This is another adaptation of a novel, this time Rum Punch by Elmore Leonard. Jackie Brown is a delight from start to finish, with a spectacular performance by Pam Grier as flight attendant turned smuggler Jackie Brown, Samuel L Jackson as her arms dealer boss and an ensemble cast that also includes Robert Forster, Bridget Fonda, Michael Keaton and Robert De Niro. According to Empire, the film solidly established director Quentin Tarantino as "still the most imporant filmmaker of the decade"; Variety loved it too, saying that it "offers an abundance of pleasures, especially in the realm of characterization and atmosphere." 

Fair Play

The most recent movie here feels like it fits well with the other two, with which it shares a similar sensibility: a mix of thriller, violent drama and erotic thriller, Newsday says it's "one of the more incisive and powerfully made movies about relationship dynamics in a good long while." Not every critic was so thrilled, but as the Independent explains that "it’s ultimately a very ugly film. That’s not its failure, but its intention. Don't let the synopsis put you off: while the film is focused on a young couple whose relationship starts to unravel following an unexpected promotion, it’s a tale of twisted love that Empire says will "keep you holding your breath until the end."

Carrie Marshall
Contributor

Writer, broadcaster, musician and kitchen gadget obsessive Carrie Marshall has been writing about tech since 1998, contributing sage advice and odd opinions to all kinds of magazines and websites as well as writing more than a dozen books. Her memoir, Carrie Kills A Man, is on sale now and her next book, about pop music, is out in 2025. She is the singer in Glaswegian rock band Unquiet Mind.

Read more
Robert DeNiro in Zero Day wearing a US flag pin badge and a smart suit
Netflix's #2 show Zero Day has viewers divided - here are 3 better political thrillers with over 85% on Rotten Tomatoes to watch instead
Pete angrily grips onto David's suit jacket in The Sentinel.
Netflix's #2 movie is a subpar thriller from 2006 – here are 3 films with better Rotten Tomatoes scores than The Sentinel
Emily Blunt in Sicario
3 thriller movies coming to Netflix with over 89% on Rotten Tomatoes
Jamie Foxx and Cameron Diaz in Back In Action
Back in Action is Netflix's new #1 movie but its bad reviews are no secret – watch these 3 with over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes instead
Jennifer Lopez in the promo for Maid in Manhattan
7 badly-rated movies with terrible Rotten Tomatoes scores I still think are worth streaming on Netflix, Prime Video, and more
Nicholas Hoult sits on the jury in Juror #2
7 underrated movies released in 2024 that you shouldn't miss streaming on Netflix, Hulu, Max and more
Latest in Netflix
Eddie Miller (Stephen Graham) looks as his anxious son Jamie (Owen Cooper) in a prison cell.
Netflix's #1 show Adolescence is one of the best crime dramas I've seen – here are 3 more with over 80% on Rotten Tomatoes
Adam Sandler as Happy Gilmore, swinging a golf club while a crowd watches
Netflix confirms Happy Gilmore's long-awaited comeback in new trailer, and I hope it won't be a swing and a miss
Stephen Graham in the Netflix show Adolescence
I can't recommend Adolescence on Netflix enough – it's the best crime drama you'll watch all year
Sakata in Demon City holds a large cleaver-like weapon
Demon City on Netflix is Japan's answer to John Wick with a dash of Oldboy, and it rocks
Cristin Milioti in Black Mirror season 7
Netflix launches trailer for Black Mirror season 7, giving us a look at its first-ever sequel episode and an unexpected returning character
A woman holds a phone and looks concerned in Caught
Netflix drops an eerie trailer for a new Harlan Coben show – I just hope Caught is better than the author's previous TV adaptations
Latest in News
Adobe AI agents
Adobe launches 10 new AI agents to automate key marketing workflows
Windows 10
Microsoft gets into the spam game by again emailing Windows 10 users to prod them to upgrade to Windows 11 – is the nagging going too far now?
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge on display the January 22, 2025 Galaxy Unpacked event.
Leaked Galaxy S25 Edge pricing gives us a clearer idea of how the super-slim phone will fit into Samsung's lineup
Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 6 in blue
The Samsung Galaxy Z Flip SE may launch months after the Galaxy Z Flip 7
ransomware avast
Billions of credentials were stolen from businesses around the world in 2024
iPhone 12
The iPhone 17 Air could come with a key charging benefit, new leak claims