Amazon removes thousands of product reviews following newspaper probe

Amazon boxes
(Image credit: Shutterstock)

Amazon has removed around 20,000 product reviews in the wake of an investigation which found seven of its leading reviewers in the UK were allegedly profiting from thousands of glowing five-star reviews after posting them on the ecommerce giant.

The probe by the Financial Times cited several examples of suspicious reviewing behaviour, with many of the high ratings being given to low-key Chinese brands. The FT uncovered evidence that some reviewers were being sent products for free. The items would then be given a highly-rated review and, in some cases, the users sample product would then be sold on eBay.

Numerous reviewers were suspected of carrying out the practice of posting 5-star reviews on Amazon, with several deleting their history following the investigation by the FT. Its analysis of the situation found that nine out the current top 10 reviewers ratings were suspicious in their nature.

Suspicious reviews

Following the FT’s publication of its findings Amazon removed all reviews on its site that had been written by seven users identified in the investigation. 

This isn’t the first time the legitimacy of product reviews have come into question. The UK’s competition watchdog, the Competition and Markets Authority carried out a similar review in May following reports of suspicious reviews appearing online.

Consumer demand for online shopping has been growing due to the coronavirus pandemic and the suspicious reviews have been following suit. Fakespot, the online review analysis group has previously suggested 58% of reviews on the Amazon UK e-commerce outlet are potentially fake.

Amazon has stated that it takes a number of measures to combat fake reviews including using AI to pick out dubious activity as well as closely monitoring its enormous database of users. It told the FT that it plans to investigate the findings.  

TOPICS
Rob Clymo

Rob Clymo has been a tech journalist for more years than he can actually remember, having started out in the wacky world of print magazines before discovering the power of the internet. Since he's been all-digital he has run the Innovation channel during a few years at Microsoft as well as turning out regular news, reviews, features and other content for the likes of TechRadar, TechRadar Pro, Tom's Guide, Fit&Well, Gizmodo, Shortlist, Automotive Interiors World, Automotive Testing Technology International, Future of Transportation and Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology International. In the rare moments he's not working he's usually out and about on one of numerous e-bikes in his collection.

Read more
A person using a smartphone with an ecommerce website showing on a laptop.
Tech deals in 2025: navigating ‘ghost’ discounts and fake reviews
Temu shopping
Temu is cheaper than archrival Amazon by 40% on average - but not the most popular products, research finds
Amazon EV Delivery Truck
Amazon will now be sending shoppers straight to a brand’s website when it doesn’t stock their products
Fake job tasks are costing victims millions, FTC warns
GitHub Webpage
GitHub has a major problem with fake rankings, which could put users at risk of attack
Someone checking their credit card details online.
Millions of credit card details leaked online - watch out if you're paying for Christmas
Latest in Pro
The socket interface of the Intel Core Ultra processor
Intel unveils its most powerful AI PCs yet - new Intel Core Ultra Series 2 processors pack in vPro for lightweight laptops and high-performance workstations alike
Webex by Cisco banner on a Chromebook
Cisco warns some Webex users of worrying security flaw, so patch now
Microsoft UK CEO Darren Hardman AI Tour London 2025
Microsoft - UK can help drive the global AI future, but only with the proper buy-in
Red padlock open on electric circuits network dark red background
AI-powered cyber threats are becoming the biggest worry for businesses everywhere
Woman using iMessage on iPhone
Apple to take legal action against British Government over backdoor request
AOC Graphic Pro U32U3CV during our review
I reviewed the AOC Graphic Pro U32U3CV and it's a staggeringly pro-grade monitor for the price
Latest in News
A hand holding a phone showing the Android Find My Device network
Android's Find My Device can now let you track your friends – and I can't decide if that's cool or creepy
Insta360 X4 360 degree camera without lens protector
Leaked DJI Osmo 360 image suggests GoPro and Insta360 should be worried – here's why
A YouTube Premium promo on a laptop screen
A cheaper YouTube Premium Lite plan just rolled out in the US – but you’ll miss out on these 4 features
Viaim RecDot AI true wireless earbuds
These AI-powered earbuds can also act as a dictaphone with transcription when left in their case
The socket interface of the Intel Core Ultra processor
Intel unveils its most powerful AI PCs yet - new Intel Core Ultra Series 2 processors pack in vPro for lightweight laptops and high-performance workstations alike
An Nvidia GeForce RTX 5070
Nvidia confirms that an RTX 5070 Founders Edition is coming... just not on launch day