The Jodie Whittaker era of Doctor Who has been far from vintage, but the show’s decline started years ago

Jodie Whittaker and the cast of Doctor Who.
(Image credit: BBC)

After months of rumors, it was no surprise when the BBC finally confirmed on July 29 that Doctor Who star Jodie Whittaker and showrunner Chris Chibnall would be leaving the show in 2022. Now the speculation about the show’s next incarnation can begin in earnest – and for Who fans, that’s always been part of the equation.

On a show that calls the whole of space and time its playground, it’s perhaps appropriate that Doctor Who’s past and future often seem more important than its present. No other science fiction TV show – not even Star Trek – has nearly six decades of existing lore to live up to. Meanwhile, theorizing about the next resident of the TARDIS is a national sport in the UK, where everybody tends to have an opinion on who’d make a good Time Lord, regardless of when they last watched the show. It’s as big a deal as casting the next James Bond.

Right now, however, the identity of the next Doctor, should be a relatively low priority for the BBC. 

Unless the truncated, six-episode series 13 (due later this year) and three subsequent specials lined up for 2022 manage to end Whittaker’s rein in a blaze of glory – and we’ll be delighted if they do – the era of the Thirteenth Doctor will not go down as a vintage one for the show. But that’s as much down to the culmination of several years of decline as it is about any particular failings of the current production team. 

If Doctor Who is going to return to the glory days of David Tennant and Russell T Davies – when it regularly went toe-to-toe with the likes of The X-Factor in the ratings and fuelled water-cooler conversations galore – there needs to be a major rethink about what Who is, and what it should be.

Jodie Whittaker in Doctor Who

Doctor Who's stories haven't always lived up to Jodie Whittaker's memorable performances. (Image credit: BBC)

The Chibnall era

As showrunner, Chibnall – who wrote episodes for earlier seasons of Doctor Who, and was also in charge of spin-off series Torchwood – has done an admirable amount to regenerate the show. When he cast the fun, likeable Whittaker (who he’d previously worked with on crime drama Broadchurch), he gave Who its first female Doctor, as well as introducing its most diverse roster of companions (or “friends”, as they’re now known) in Ryan (Tosin Cole), Yaz (Mandip Gill) and Graham (Bradley Walsh) – a policy he repeated on the other side of the camera with an all-new line-up of writers and directors. 

Historical episodes also moved into politically relevant time zones, with ‘Rosa’ taking in the US civil rights movement, ‘Demons of the Punjab’ travelling to partition-era India, and ‘The Witchfinders’ visiting 17th century witch trials.

Alongside a move to make the show feel more cinematic with anamorphic lenses, Chibnall has also overseen some brave storytelling decisions, from a talking frog (much better than it sounds), to the Timeless Child arc. Indeed, as divisive as it was, the idea that the Doctor is the source of the Time Lords’ regeneration abilities is arguably the biggest shake-up in the show’s mythology since William Hartnell regenerated into Patrick Troughton over 50 years ago.

And yet, despite the first Whittaker/Chibnall season getting Doctor Who’s best ratings for years – although there was a significant drop-off in their second year, the numbers were still comparable or better than predecessor Peter Capaldi’s final run  – the execution hasn’t always matched the ambition. Too many stories have been inoffensively average, with the humor that characterized the Russell T. Davies and Steven Moffat eras largely conspicuous by its absence – how the show has missed the sort of memorable gags that could put a sticking plaster over a misfiring plot. 

Aside from classic villains the Master, the Daleks and the Cybermen, few monsters have stuck in the memory, and while that’s no crime in itself – of the New Who pantheon, it’s arguably only the Weeping Angels who’ve earned themselves a place at the bad guy top table – there haven’t been enough of the PG-friendly scares that have traditionally been one of the show’s hallmarks.

David Tennant as the Doctor

David Tennant as the Doctor during the show's glory years. (Image credit: BBC)

Back to the drawing board

Perhaps most importantly, this era of Who has repeatedly suffered from an overly-packed TARDIS, with the Doctor’s travelling companions proving that three’s a crowd; Yaz was particularly underserved by her first season, while Ryan and Graham’s New Year’s Day departure was spectacularly anti-climactic.

Fundamentally, though, Chibnall hasn’t changed much about the Doctor Who formula, and he’s perhaps unfortunate to have inherited the series over a decade into its rebooted run. Even in Matt Smith and Capaldi’s tenures (both under Moffat’s watch), the show was starting to feel less essential – suddenly, a show that many would have moved mountains to watch ‘live’ on TV was relegated to catch-up status.

As much time has now passed since Doctor Who’s triumphant return as it was off air following the BBC pulling the plug in 1989. Where Davies had the luxury of making his early seasons an ‘entry point’ show – knowing that an entire generation had been unable to see the TARDIS on TV – Chibnall is wrestling with 16 years of New Who continuity, and the perception that we've seen it all before. That’s before you’ve even addressed the legacy of the show’s original 26-year run.

In a world where big-budget sci-fi TV has become the norm on Netflix, Amazon, Disney Plus and beyond, Doctor Who has simply started to feel like part of the furniture. So, rather than rushing to find replacements for Whittaker and Chibnall, the BBC needs to work out what adventures through space and time look like in the era of streaming giants – even if it means going away for three or four years to do it.

Doctor Who is among the greatest, most versatile TV formats on planet Earth. It shouldn’t take a Time Lord-size intellect to make it feel like a must-watch once again.

Doctor Who returns to BBC America and BBC One later this year.

Richard Edwards

Richard is a freelance journalist specialising in movies and TV, primarily of the sci-fi and fantasy variety. An early encounter with a certain galaxy far, far away started a lifelong love affair with outer space, and these days Richard's happiest geeking out about Star Wars, Star Trek, Marvel and other long-running pop culture franchises. In a previous life he was editor of legendary sci-fi and fantasy magazine SFX, where he got to interview many of the biggest names in the business – though he'll always have a soft spot for Jeff Goldblum who (somewhat bizarrely) thought Richard's name was Winter.

Read more
The TV posters for Doctor Who: Joy to the World, Squid Game season 2 and What if...? season 3 in a collage.
7 new movies and TV shows to stream on Netflix, Prime Video, Disney Plus, and more this weekend (December 27)
Ncuti Gatwa as The Fifteenth Doctor in Doctor Who
The trailer for Doctor Who's new season promises new mysteries, creepy cartoons and musical madness
Mark S holding a red ball while smiling and sitting down in Severance season 2
5 returning TV shows I’m most excited to stream in 2025
The Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa) and Joy (Nicola Coughlan) face down danger in 'Joy to the World', the 2024 Doctor Who Christmas Special
How to watch the Doctor Who 2024 Christmas special online – stream 'Joy to the World' for free
The TV show posters for The Secret Lives of Animals, The Six Triple Eight and Virgin River season 6 in a collage.
7 new movies and TV shows to stream on Netflix, Prime Video, Max, and more this weekend (December 20)
A collage image showing pictures from X-Men 97, Squid Game season 2, and Fallout season 1
The 50 best shows of 2024: TechRadar's top TV picks of the year on Netflix, Prime Video, Max, Disney Plus, and more
Latest in Entertainment
Trinity Rodman #2 of the Washington Spirit crosses the ball during a game between Bay FC and Washington Spirit at Audi Field on November 10, 2024 in Washington, DC.
National Women's Soccer League 2025: How to watch NWSL games live from anywhere
Irish boxer TJ Doheny receives an undercard bout, ahead of the WBO super welterweight world title fight in March, 2023
Ball vs Doheny live stream: how to watch the boxing from anywhere now, full undercard, start time, weigh-in results
Bruno Guimaraes of Newcastle United during the Carabao Cup Semi Final Second Leg match in February 2025
Liverpool vs Newcastle live stream: how to watch Carabao Cup final 2025 online, team news
The Russo brothers posing for a photograph and Herman carrying a Volkswagen camper van in The Electric State
'We're optimists': AI enthusiasts Joe and Anthony Russo defend its use in movies and TV shows, but admit there are 'very real dangers' around its application
Lando Norris driving around a bend during practice for the 2025 Australian Grand Prix
Australian Grand Prix 2025: How to watch this season’s first F1 race online from anywhere
A collage of Tom Holland's unmasked Spider-Man and Sadie Sink's Max in Stranger Things season 4
Marvel reportedly casts Stranger Things star Sadie Sink in Spider-Man 4, but I don't want her to tackle the roles she's rumored to play
Latest in News
Google Pixel 8a in aloe green showing
Google Pixel 9a benchmark link teases the performance of the upcoming mid-ranger
Quordle on a smartphone held in a hand
Quordle hints and answers for Monday, March 17 (game #1148)
NYT Strands homescreen on a mobile phone screen, on a light blue background
NYT Strands hints and answers for Monday, March 17 (game #379)
NYT Connections homescreen on a phone, on a purple background
NYT Connections hints and answers for Monday, March 17 (game #645)
Apple iPhone 16 Pro HANDS ON
Leaked iPhone 17 dummy units may have given us our best look yet at all four models
A super close up image of the Google Gemini app in the Play Store
It's official: Google Assistant will be retired for phones this year, with Gemini taking over