AI is rubbish at Christmas. I beat ChatGPT in a Christmas carol writing contest

carol sheet
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Yeah, that’s right. AI is rubbish at Christmas. Bah, humbug to you and your gibberish, ChatGPT.

There I was listening on the radio with yet another year of Christmas ker-ching for all the regulars with their festive playback royalties, and it occurred to me that maybe I could have a Christmas no. 1 of my own! Because everyone needs a side hustle these days and how hard can a festive hit be with generative AI at the ready?

The first problem I had was what to write my song about. They say you should write about what you know, so a world-first cybersecurity Christmas classic seemed perfect for mass appeal. Then it was over to ChatGPT for some Wenceslas-style wordplay – but the results were hideous.

What I got was a list of some of the most carelessly crowbarred phrases into Christmas carol titles. Fancy listening to a bit of Firewall the Way or O Come, O Come, Secure IP? I thought not. How about I Saw Three Data Streams or Tracking-free is coming to town?

Has there really been any effort here to think about the sense of these suggestions? I think OpenAI might be on the sherry already.

After "Hark! The VPN Tunnels Sing", "Proxy Wonderland", and "Oh the Latency Outside Is Frightful", I decided that enough was enough. I rolled my sleeves up and had a go at songwriting the old-fashioned way.

So, here it is! Sticking to the AI's themes, I've gone with a cybersecurity-inspired Christmas carol. It's not going to make me any yuletide millions – unless Michael Bublé changes tack and decides he's going to cover it – but I've certainly read worse, and I'm definitely more Christmas-y than a machine. For one more year, at least.


Encrypt ye, merry gentlemen,
Let's hope you do not find
Your bank account and home address
Are being sold online
A VPN will fix your woes and
Loe, I hope you'll find
O tidings of safe searches online, searches online
O tidings of safe searches online

When you decide to search online
A band of thieves can swarm
A VPN is software through which
Secure tunnels form
They keep your traffic secret so
They’re not in vulnerable form
O tidings of safe searches online, searches online
O tidings of safe searches online

If speed is a concern of yours
Those woes can go away
With WireGuard your broadband speeds
Are more than here to stay
And OpenVPN supports
Secure and speedy days
O tidings of safe searches online, searches online
O tidings of safe searches online

When traveling far away to shores
Where shows you love don’t show
A VPN can help you find
A secure way to go
Unblocking films from Netflix or
Shows from HBO
O tidings of safe searches online, searches online
O tidings of safe searches online

To VPNs sing praises
All those upon this site
For a more secure time online
The future doth look bright
With features added all the time
These systems have such might
O tidings of safe searches online, searches online
O tidings of safe searches online

Rob Dunne
Deals Editor

Rob is the Mobile and Broadband Deals Editor for TechRadar. Coming from years of experience working with phones on shop floors and giving customers the best deals on their tech, Rob is the dream adviser for readers looking to save money on top mobiles, accessories and broadband no matter what their needs are. Whether it's helpful information and expertise, niche benefits, or simply finding the best value for money, Rob has the know-how to guide you in the right direction towards your next tech endeavour. Outside of work, you'll find Rob on the tennis courts, in the gym, or diving into the biggest and best games of the year.